1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

For Manly Sea Eagles fans, now is the winter of our discontent

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Brookie Brawler, Apr 18, 2015.

  1. Brookie Brawler

    Brookie Brawler Well-Known Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

    612
    215
    Ratings:
    +444 /6
    By MALCOLM KNOX in SMH 18/4/15

    Toovey or not Toovey? That is the question for Manly (if you ask the chairman) or not (if you ask the chief executive), pretty much standard on-the-same-pageness between the club's board and management.

    It is no secret that something is rotten in the state of Brookvale. Now Bob Fulton has been appointed the club's "strategic consultant", which is nice, because it's good to have a strategy, and very modern indeed to have consultants. Any year now, the Sea Eagles will also have a computer, and just watch them go then.

    The play's the thing, however, for Manly, and after a decade of excellence the football team has lost its faculty for covering over the club's infighting and other off-field mayhem. Whether 'tis nobler for the Sea Eagles to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous misfortune and a lengthy injured list, or just give up the ghost, seems to be the problem facing coach and players on a weekly basis. The injuries have come, like sorrows, not in singles but in battalions. Brett Stewart, Jorge Taufua, Jamie Lyon, Steve Matai, Kieran Foran, Clint Gutherson, Jesse Sene-Lafao, Tom Trbojevic, Brenton Lawrence, Feleti Mateo, Josh Starling – not a team list for Manly this season, but an appointment schedule for the club doctor.

    Rejoice not, ye unbelievers, because injuries are not just Manly's problem but the entire NRL's. A worthy international team could be made up from the players currently out injured. Billy Slater, Darius Boyd, Jamal Idris, Brett Morris, Semi Radradra, Jamie Soward, Adam Reynolds, John Sutton, Aidan Guerra, Beau Scott, Adam Blair, Ben Henry, Dave Shillington, Dylan Walker, Blake Ferguson, Tim Lafai, David Fifita: you don't even need to tap the Manly wounded to come up with a top-class casualty 17.

    Is there a systemic problem that is robbing the league of so many of its drawcards, or is it just coincidence? Nobody can point to anything other than the speed and impact of the game itself, which is perhaps the most worrying trend of all. Self-destruction is as much a rugby league addiction as video-ref replays, but could the game be literally destroying itself? When players are fed and trained up into 110-kilo torpedoes being fired at each other with unprecedented speed and precision, wouldn't serious injuries be the norm rather than the exception? The protection of small playmakers from late hits is a bigger priority than ever because they are being hit by bigger men than ever.

    Injuries actually could emerge, by the end of this season, as the NRL's biggest issue, bigger even than refereeing. Debates over the salary cap will hardly be relevant when each club is spending half its money on guys who are not able to play. The premiers will be the team least affected by injuries. That's not a prediction, it's a fact. It's also not very interesting. It will be an awful shame if the opposing halfbacks in the grand final are Glenn Stewart and Mitch Aubusson. Whether anything can be done about it is, unlike league's other issues, a real problem because it is intractable. The suggested reform to the interchange rule sounds like a good idea if only because fewer replacements might bring down the average size of the NRL player, but it's going to be hard to address problems of excessive size, speed and destructiveness when those factors are league's biggest appeal.

    But back to Manly's implosion (so much for diversion tactics). Throughout the Hasler-Toovey era, Manly have never been a team noted for their attention to detail. Going into games without a back-up goalkicker? That's Manly. Taken by surprise and unable to defend against short kick-offs? Manly. Dopey fifth-tackle options? Even at their best, that was a Manly trademark. Compared with Craig Bellamy's Melbourne, Trent Robinson's Roosters or Michael Maguire's Rabbitohs, the Sea Eagles were notably inattentive to the one-percenters. They won premierships despite their flakiness. They dominated through brutal simplicity and a dash of brilliance from their halves and fullback. Detail didn't matter so much. Their era didn't end with the loss of Glenn Stewart and Anthony Watmough, it ended with the loss of Brent Kite and Joe Galuvao a year earlier, it just took a while to sink in.

    Now that the enthusiastic muscle has gone, all the other cracks stand revealed, and Manly suddenly look like a poorly coached team when they are probably coached just the same way as during their seven or eight years as the best team in the NRL. You feel sorry for Toovey (or at least I do) because if he is a bad coach now, then he was also a bad coach when he took Manly to a grand final and two other good years. What's changed is that this year he only has about eight fit first-grade-quality players.

    With the appointment of Fulton, Manly's staff is on notice, from Toovey through to his assistants David Penna and Steve Georgallis and football manager Dave Warwick. (Alas, poor Warwick!) This year, there's been a bit too much of "We can't get the wooden spoon because we're Manly, and Manly never gets the wooden spoon". It's magical, lazy thinking: to sleep, perchance to dream of a form turnaround. Everyone in the football division is denying there's a problem and backing Toovey to the hilt, as you would expect, but sometimes, as the bard said, they doth protest too much.

    Anyway, this is probably of no relevance to the rest of the league, except those who want to enjoy the spectacle like rubber-neckers slowing down at a crash site. Nobody since Arko could hold seriously to the view that a strong Manly means a strong league, but the club's injury list is a pointer to something that will soon be a preoccupation of every club. The Eagles are canaries down that particular mineshaft. In the meantime, I'm off to that popular eatery on the Corso, Hamlet's, formerly Shakespeare's, to see if Manly's still capable of scoring some meat pies. Who said the northern beaches were a cultural wasteland?
    --------------------------------------------
    Good read again from Knox I thought. Particularly interesting point about lack of preparation, which I agree with with 100%.
     
    Last edited: Apr 18, 2015
  2. malroon

    malroon Active Member

    197
    67
    Redfern West
    Ratings:
    +102 /7
    I think he only has 8 FIRST GRADE players full stop..!!!!!
     
  3. Budgewoi Eagle

    Budgewoi Eagle In for the long haul. Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor 2016 Tipping Competitor

    2,885
    1,607
    Ratings:
    +4,766 /62
    He's right about Joe G and Kitey.
     
  4. conanu

    conanu Well-Known Member Premium Member

    Ratings:
    +2,212 /45
    it was a good read, nice to see a Manly journo put his view out there.
     
  5. Mark from Brisbane

    Mark from Brisbane Living the dream Premium Member

    17,479
    5,762
    Brisbane
    Ratings:
    +14,811 /286
    Spot on the money I feel!!
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • SeaEagleRock8

      SeaEagleRock8 Sea Eagle Lach Staff Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

      13,248
      3,721
      Ratings:
      +7,877 /149
      The point about injuries throughout the NRL is one I have made here previously. I might contact the Players Association and see whether they have any thoughts on this.
       
    • lismore_fan

      lismore_fan Well-Known Member

      Lismore
      Ratings:
      +206 /1
      Malcolm Knox SMH 18/4/15

      [​IMG]
      Malcolm Knox
      Sports columnist
      View more articles from Malcolm Knox



      [img alt="" title="" src="http://www.smh.com.au/content/dam/i...LeadNarrow.300x0.1mmvdg.png/1429292295173.jpg" itemprop="image">
      Illustration: Simon Letch


      Toovey or not Toovey? That is the question for Manly (if you ask the chairman) or not (if you ask the chief executive), pretty much standard on-the-same-pageness between the club's board and management.

      It is no secret that something is rotten in the state of Brookvale. Now Bob Fulton has been appointed the club's "strategic consultant", which is nice, because it's good to have a strategy, and very modern indeed to have consultants. Any year now, the Sea Eagles will also have a computer, and just watch them go then.

      The play's the thing, however, for Manly, and after a decade of excellence the football team has lost its faculty for covering over the club's infighting and other off-field mayhem. Whether 'tis nobler for the Sea Eagles to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous misfortune and a lengthy injured list, or just give up the ghost, seems to be the problem facing coach and players on a weekly basis. The injuries have come, like sorrows, not in singles but in battalions. Brett Stewart, Jorge Taufua, Jamie Lyon, Steve Matai, Kieran Foran, Clint Gutherson, Jesse Sene-Lafao, Tom Trbojevic, Brenton Lawrence, Feleti Mateo, Josh Starling – not a team list for Manly this season, but an appointment schedule for the club doctor.

      Rejoice not, ye unbelievers, because injuries are not just Manly's problem but the entire NRL's. A worthy international team could be made up from the players currently out injured. Billy Slater, Darius Boyd, Jamal Idris, Brett Morris, Semi Radradra, Jamie Soward, Adam Reynolds, John Sutton, Aidan Guerra, Beau Scott, Adam Blair, Ben Henry, Dave Shillington, Dylan Walker, Blake Ferguson, Tim Lafai, David Fifita: you don't even need to tap the Manly wounded to come up with a top-class casualty 17.

      Advertisement
      Is there a systemic problem that is robbing the league of so many of its drawcards, or is it just coincidence? Nobody can point to anything other than the speed and impact of the game itself, which is perhaps the most worrying trend of all. Self-destruction is as much a rugby league addiction as video-ref replays, but could the game be literally destroying itself? When players are fed and trained up into 110-kilo torpedoes being fired at each other with unprecedented speed and precision, wouldn't serious injuries be the norm rather than the exception? The protection of small playmakers from late hits is a bigger priority than ever because they are being hit by bigger men than ever.

      Injuries actually could emerge, by the end of this season, as the NRL's biggest issue, bigger even than refereeing. Debates over the salary cap will hardly be relevant when each club is spending half its money on guys who are not able to play. The premiers will be the team least affected by injuries. That's not a prediction, it's a fact. It's also not very interesting. It will be an awful shame if the opposing halfbacks in the grand final are Glenn Stewart and Mitch Aubusson. Whether anything can be done about it is, unlike league's other issues, a real problem because it is intractable. The suggested reform to the interchange rule sounds like a good idea if only because fewer replacements might bring down the average size of the NRL player, but it's going to be hard to address problems of excessive size, speed and destructiveness when those factors are league's biggest appeal.

      But back to Manly's implosion (so much for diversion tactics). Throughout the Hasler-Toovey era, Manly have never been a team noted for their attention to detail. Going into games without a back-up goalkicker? That's Manly. Taken by surprise and unable to defend against short kick-offs? Manly. Dopey fifth-tackle options? Even at their best, that was a Manly trademark. Compared with Craig Bellamy's Melbourne, Trent Robinson's Roosters or Michael Maguire's Rabbitohs, the Sea Eagles were notably inattentive to the one-percenters. They won premierships despite their flakiness. They dominated through brutal simplicity and a dash of brilliance from their halves and fullback. Detail didn't matter so much. Their era didn't end with the loss of Glenn Stewart and Anthony Watmough, it ended with the loss of Brent Kite and Joe Galuvao a year earlier, it just took a while to sink in.

      Now that the enthusiastic muscle has gone, all the other cracks stand revealed, and Manly suddenly look like a poorly coached team when they are probably coached just the same way as during their seven or eight years as the best team in the NRL. You feel sorry for Toovey (or at least I do) because if he is a bad coach now, then he was also a bad coach when he took Manly to a grand final and two other good years. What's changed is that this year he only has about eight fit first-grade-quality players.

      With the appointment of Fulton, Manly's staff is on notice, from Toovey through to his assistants David Penna and Steve Georgallis and football manager Dave Warwick. (Alas, poor Warwick!) This year, there's been a bit too much of "We can't get the wooden spoon because we're Manly, and Manly never gets the wooden spoon". It's magical, lazy thinking: to sleep, perchance to dream of a form turnaround. Everyone in the football division is denying there's a problem and backing Toovey to the hilt, as you would expect, but sometimes, as the bard said, they doth protest too much.

      Anyway, this is probably of no relevance to the rest of the league, except those who want to enjoy the spectacle like rubber-neckers slowing down at a crash site. Nobody since Arko could hold seriously to the view that a strong Manly means a strong league, but the club's injury list is a pointer to something that will soon be a preoccupation of every club. The Eagles are canaries down that particular mineshaft. In the meantime, I'm off to that popular eatery on the Corso, Hamlet's, formerly Shakespeare's, to see if Manly's still capable of scoring some meat pies. Who said the northern beaches were a cultural wasteland?
       
      • Like Like x 1
      • Moondog

        Moondog Amazing Blue Footed Boobie 2017 Tipping Competitor

        5,343
        2,135
        Hervey Bay
        Ratings:
        +4,140 /35
        Bull**** by some try hard with a strangely shaped head probably written on the prison typewriter.
         
        • Like Like x 1
        • Mavin

          Mavin Well-Known Member

          Ratings:
          +929 /43
          He is 1 of the only journo's who is a Manly fan.
           
          • Like Like x 4
          • Moondog

            Moondog Amazing Blue Footed Boobie 2017 Tipping Competitor

            5,343
            2,135
            Hervey Bay
            Ratings:
            +4,140 /35
            In that case I forgive him (and I quite like the shape of his head).
             
            • Like Like x 3
            • Mavin

              Mavin Well-Known Member

              Ratings:
              +929 /43
              lol
               
            • wombatgc

              wombatgc Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

              3,973
              1,083
              Gold Coast
              Ratings:
              +3,443 /59
              He should stick to reviews on his local theatre group.
               
              • Like Like x 2
              • NYEagle

                NYEagle Well-Known Member

                Ratings:
                +1,303 /75
              • bob dylan

                bob dylan Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

                7,020
                2,081
                Junee
                Ratings:
                +4,845 /141
                I stopped reading about 25% of the way through.

                Imagine putting your name to that rubbish.
                 
                • Like Like x 2
                • Kevinward777

                  Kevinward777 Well-Known Member

                  Ratings:
                  +1,904 /47
                  Absolute turd!
                   
                • KOMORI

                  KOMORI Born and bred an Eagle

                  3,819
                  1,088
                  Brisbane
                  Ratings:
                  +3,497 /60
                  A fan huh?

                  Why write such a f*ckwit of an article?
                   
                • Baz

                  Baz Beaver's Headgear

                  268
                  166
                  Ratings:
                  +271 /2
                  Nothing really wrong with the article but not as good as his others. Maybe the editor told him to tone down his Manly bias, because this article almost sounded like he doesn't like us anymore...
                   
                • Simonmyers11

                  Simonmyers11 Well-Known Member

                  Ratings:
                  +2,426 /114
                  What's wrong with that article. Its not bull****, its the truth. Its exactly how we have won premierships and been successful. And we are probably still being coached the same way but just don't have the enthusiastic muscle any more and brilliance of the halves and backs. We did use to do some dumb things but we had so many brilliant players and such a strong desire to compete and win it kept us at the top for a long sustained period. All the coaching staff and players should be on notice, because there is a very big chance we will get the spoon
                   
                  • Like Like x 3
                  • lismore_fan

                    lismore_fan Well-Known Member

                    Lismore
                    Ratings:
                    +206 /1
                    I'm with you, Simon.
                    I thought that I was a 'glass half-full' kind of guy.

                    The one-percenters that Manly does so often really annoy the crap out of me and this guy has nailed our playing style. We have used the same sweeping back line movement with the fullback chiming in since 2004. At some time, albeit 11 years later, the other Clubs must know what's coming. Come 2015, we can't seem to get the ball along the back-line without a fumble or a knock-on, or worse still, without the opposition creaming us before it gets to the outside centre.
                     
                    • Like Like x 1
                    • simon64

                      simon64 Well-Known Member Premium Member

                      2,343
                      1,014
                      Ratings:
                      +2,193 /29
                      ...He took too long to get to the point. I stopped reading.
                      I did, however, read the part where "every team has injuries".
                      Is he serious ? No side (not even Penrith) have anything like our injury toll.
                       

                    Share This Page