Hindmarsh 9984 tackles

[nodd]

Choc,Stewart,Rodney,Joe,Gallen,Bird,Anasta need i say more Nodd?

No I think you've said quite enough.

 

[The Eagle]

[quote author=Shane link=topic=187049.msg326937#msg326937 date=1300950261]
Choc,Stewart,Rodney,Joe,Gallen,Bird,Anasta need i say more Nodd?

No I think you've said quite enough.


[/quote]

You made the challenge i just owned it,even Anasta can be a better player,but Hindy is a better bloke than most of them

 

[swoop]

Hindmarsh was forced to do most of the defensive work because the rest of the slime wouldn't do the hard yakka, but that has come at a cost.

When he was at his best he was equally great in attack and defence but in recent years has been overlooked for rep duties because he has nothing in attack after all the work he does in defence.

 

[TokyoEagle]

For every player that can turn a game with a piece of brilliance, you need a Hindmarsh who just digs in and does all the dirty work to keep your team in the battle.

 

[Masked Eagle]

I actually think he's starting to slow down a little bit this year.  I've seen a few times when he was at marker and get left for dead trying to tackle the dummy half if he takes off.  That used to be a bread a butter play for him and he'd make 2, 3, 4 tackles in a row by doing that.

Champion player although I think the leading one on one tackling stat is more important than overall tackles.

 

[nodd]

[quote author=nodd link=topic=187049.msg327000#msg327000 date=1300966614]
[quote author=Shane link=topic=187049.msg326937#msg326937 date=1300950261]
Choc,Stewart,Rodney,Joe,Gallen,Bird,Anasta need i say more Nodd?

No I think you've said quite enough.


[/quote]

You made the challenge i just owned it,even Anasta can be a better player,but Hindy is a better bloke than most of them
[/quote]

If You think you "owned" me with that list, good on You.

I know who I would rather have on the field with me from that mob, and that icludes the Manly blokes.

 

[Wolfpack]

[quote author=Wolfpack link=topic=187049.msg326737#msg326737 date=1300913986]
[quote author=DSM5 link=topic=187049.msg326612#msg326612 date=1300863499]
Totally over-rated.  A player who makes that many tackles leaves himself exhausted, and his team in peril.  All he's good for is showing his bum-crack.  Give me a Kennedy any day over this hack.

For sure DSM. Hindmarsh is one of the most over-rated players in the NRL today.

Decent player but nothing overly special. There are quite a lot of back rowers that leave him in the dust. Being a media darling doesn't make him a good player, nor does Gould's constant fawning over him.
[/quote]

Care to name them?
[/quote]

Gift, Choc, Parker, Harrison, Gallen, Young, Johnson & Blair are a few names off the top of my head.

A lot of younger guys coming through like Gillett & Fensom who I would have in a team over Hindmarsh as well given their potential.

Sure Hindmarsh was in the top tier of backrowers before but the bloke is past it now. His work ethic is great but he'll continue to slow down as he has been over the past few seasons. His body won't continue to hold up when he's making 30+ tackles a game & he is fairly impotent in attack now. Give him another 2-3 years in the league & you can stick a fork in him.

 

[nodd]

[quote author=nodd link=topic=187049.msg326888#msg326888 date=1300944628]
[quote author=Wolfpack link=topic=187049.msg326737#msg326737 date=1300913986]

Read above.
[quote author=DSM5 link=topic=187049.msg326612#msg326612 date=1300863499]
Totally over-rated.  A player who makes that many tackles leaves himself exhausted, and his team in peril.  All he's good for is showing his bum-crack.  Give me a Kennedy any day over this hack.

For sure DSM. Hindmarsh is one of the most over-rated players in the NRL today.

Decent player but nothing overly special. There are quite a lot of back rowers that leave him in the dust. Being a media darling doesn't make him a good player, nor does Gould's constant fawning over him.
[/quote]

Care to name them?
[/quote]

Gift, Choc, Parker, Harrison, Gallen, Young, Johnson & Blair are a few names off the top of my head.

A lot of younger guys coming through like Gillett & Fensom who I would have in a team over Hindmarsh as well given their potential.

Sure Hindmarsh was in the top tier of backrowers before but the bloke is past it now. His work ethic is great but he'll continue to slow down as he has been over the past few seasons. His body won't continue to hold up when he's making 30+ tackles a game & he is fairly impotent in attack now. Give him another 2-3 years in the league & you can stick a fork in him.
[/quote]

---

Post  automatically merged: [time]1301142497[/time]

---

Sorry! Read above.

 

[The Eagle]

I dont think,i know