Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Napper, Jun 6, 2012.
And you could choose another handful of players for Manly, how would your team look?
Slater SBW Inglis and that's with respect to current players
1 Snake 2 Uate 3 Lyon 4 Matai 5 Robertson 6 Foran 7 DCE 8 Gallen 9 Ballin 10 Shillington 11 Choc 12 Pritchard 13 Glenn 14 Trex 15 Fui Fui 16 Tariq Sims 17 Thurston
We would have a crap team. Storm, Roosters, Eels and Dogs would have the best of the best signed up. We don't have the funds to match teams like that. 20 years ago we would sign anyone we wanted with the funds we had.
No need to change much. Im easy pleased. Our full strength line up is great as it is. I love Ballin but i think id have Cam Smith at hooker. One of the best rugby league players ive ever seen.
sub SBW with Cam Smith massive Paul gallen fan disclaimer: cant stand slater and smith on the footy field but they are good
1 Brett Stewart 2 Matt Duffie 3 Jamie Lyon 4 Steve Matai 5 Jarryd Hayne 6 Kieran Foran 7 DCE 8 Matt Scott 9 Matt Ballin 10 Sam Burgess 11 Anthony Watmough 12 Tariq Sims 13 Glenn Stewart 14 Jamie Buhrer 15 Darcy Lussick 16 Trent Merrin 17 Dave Taylor
Yeah obviously. Just interested in opinions on who people would chop and change.
1 brett stewart 2 uate 3 jamie lyon 4 greg inglis 5 jarryd hayne 6 kerian foran 7 thurston 8 Matt scott 9 robbie farah 10 Tamou 11 watmough 12 stewart 13 gallen 14 jason king 15 tony williams 16 ben hannant 17 dave taylor
. . . Brisbane would win the comp every year. They would attract ever Queensland player.
1. B. Stewart 2. W.Hopate 3. S. Matai 4. J. Lyon 5. J. Hayne 6. K. Foran 7. D. Cherry Evans 8. M. Scott 9. C. Smith 10. P. Gallen 11. A. Watmough 12. T. Sims 13. G. Stewart 14. T. Williams 15. J. Buhrer 16. S. Burgess 17. J. Tamou If only...
We'd come 3rd last
1.B Stewart 2.Uate 3.Lyon 4.Matai 5.Hopoate 6.Foran 7.DCE 8.Gallen 9.Ballin 10.Burgess 11.Watmough 12.T-Rex 13.G Stewart 14.Buhrer 15.King 16.Lussick 17.T Sims Can't let go of Kingy, his Manly through and through. So he gets a couple of seasons more than Tamou, Woods or Grant come in
If there were no salary cap, what would people wear on their heads?
Including the ones from Fiji and New Zealand...
If there were no salary cap, David Gallop would have been fired a long time ago. Stripping premierships from the Melbourne Storm for no reason wouldn't have went down well.
If there was no salary cap Melbourne, Brisabne and Canterbury would play out each grand final. Others may get a look in now and then but any good player would be poached by the other sides. No one else wuld get a chance. Having said that the salary cap should be used in conjunction with a points system. (only my opinion.)
Im against a points system I believe in a loyalty system where when players play for the same club for 7 years they are excluded from the salary cap altogether
I don't know about that. I wouldn't have had a problem with it.
Yep I'd agree with this...if there was no cap we might as well have a two tier competition. Storm / Brisbane / Dogs...and whoever wins the second tier the year before. They only play each other, continuously in a comp of just 4 sides, that also guarantees that TV always get top class games. There's no need for this "finding out at the last minute when a game is being played" as it can be decided 5 years in advance. It's Brisbane V Storm on Friday night and the second game is Buldogs V XXXX. Obviously they take all the Free to Air TV Spots so there's no need for Foxtel and Chanel 9 can pay One Billion a year for rights as they'll have the lot. Naturally the four in the top tier also take all the sponsorship dollars leaving the second tier sides to survive on chook raffles and the profits from the sausage sizzles they run at home games. At the end of each year the winner of the second tier (also known as the "bottom dwellers") gets to play in the comp known as "the big league", this is considered a great honour as for 6 months the players can be considered "real players" of the game and get a huge bonus in match payments during this period. The previous years winner drops back the bottom dwellers after completing a year in the "big league" and the next winner comes up to spend a year in the "big league", this is considered one of the greatest hionours in the game. A new innovation is that the same team can't win the "bottom dwellers" comp two years in a row, this guarantees that a new team gets elevated to the "big league" every year. Players in the "Big League" are on a minumum salary of one million dollars per annum but this can go higher, and often sparks a bidding war between the three "big league" clubs...why just last year Billy Seeyalater was offered an incredible $500K per game to move from the Storm to the Bronco's...AND he declined leaving fans wondering at how big the paper bags really were at Melbourne HQ. Players in the "bottom dwellers" league get match payments of $500 a game and all have jobs. The CEO of the game, now known as the "Rich Boys League" (or the short version RBL) is the previous CEO of what was once known as the NRL, yes the one and only David Gallop is in control again. It's exciting times in the RBL, with mining magnates Clive Palmer backing the Bronco's, Nathan Tinkler backing the Bulldogs but the biggest of the lot Gina Reinhart backs the Melbourne Storm. This years 4th team the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles won the "bottom dwellers cup" (also known as the BDC) last year and are doing a great job of putting it to the top teams. Last week they actually scored a field goal against the current RBL leader the Clive Palmer Bronco's, but sadly for the long suffering Eagles fans the game was still lost 78-1. But the Eagles fans can raise their heads this year as they have managed to score a try (yes just one), which is something that hasn't happened against any of the "big three" for over 5 years. Current Bulldogs CEO Bod Greenturd has been sacked as a result of the shame caused by the letting in of the first try scored by a "bottom dweller" in over 5 years. Investigations into the matter continue!!
Separate names with a comma.