Judiciary

[jbay]

Does anyone think we’ll have any issues through the week with the judiciary

 

[Sea Eagle 4 Life]

No, unless Manly loading comes into play.

 

[Dan]

Does anyone think we’ll have any issues through the week with the judiciary

Guac will miss 2 weeks for that haircut

 

[Nordburg]

DCE will be fine given the hit had minimal impact and he has a squeaky clean record

 

[jbay]

No, unless Manly loading comes into play.

Maybe Lawton

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

They’ll need 68 sittings of the judiciary to get through them all.

There’s about 10 per game

 

[Dion Johnson]

That holistic Judiciary list is bigger this week than last week with fines and suspensions.

Hopefully ours are just fines when they review them.

 

[voicefromthehill]

Maybe Lawton

I hope not - the player was as much spun around in to him as a driving shoulder

I watched the game with a group of Parr mates (not sure mates is the right word) and they agreed a tough 10 min on that one

 

[40 years an eagle]

Guac will miss 2 weeks for that haircut

Maybe just a fine for a first offense...the others should be ok.

 

[Dan]

Maybe just a fine for a first offense...the others should be ok.

True, gutho should get the same fine though

 

[40 years an eagle]

True, gutho should get the same fine though

Nah, 2 weeks suspension for him...he is a cereal offender.

 

[Dan]

Nah, 2 weeks suspension for him...he is a cereal offender.

Definitely high in fibre with that man bun

 

[The better Robbo]

Lawton grade 1 probably. Everyone else should be fine

 

[Damien2812]

This is going to be the biggest blight to the game. Every week will be long lists of fines and suspensions which means we the fans get robbed of seeing the best players on the field due to this poor crack down.

 

[malroon]

*

 

[The Who]

I'f anyone should worry about concussion it's the judiciary members.
They must be banging their heads in frustration about the extra work they are being forced to do, much of it unnecessary.

 

[The better Robbo]

I'f anyone should worry about concussion it's the judiciary members.
They must be banging their heads in frustration about the extra work they are being forced to do, much of it unnecessary.

Most aren't going to Judiciary to fight it. It's the Match review committee copping all the extra work. They've really gotta stop sin binning the minor head shots. If its not at least a grade 2 then a penalty should be sufficient! Also if a player stays down and milks a penalty they should have to go for a mandatory HIA, that'll stop NRL turning into soccer. What we've seen with players staying down is a joke!

 

[eadie fan]

Most aren't going to Judiciary to fight it. It's the Match review committee copping all the extra work. They've really gotta stop sin binning the minor head shots. If its not at least a grade 2 then a penalty should be sufficient! Also if a player stays down and milks a penalty they should have to go for a mandatory HIA, that'll stop NRL turning into soccer. What we've seen with players staying down is a joke!

I agree that players are staying down to make sure it is reviewed. It was great to see Guaca not stay down even though he was rubbery-legged - unlike Brown, the bloody cat.

 

[globaleagle]

I wonder if the MRC will eventually go:

Screw this, "select all...delete"

everyone gets off!

 

[Cliffymagic]

Seems Lawton and Sipley are copping fines and that's it. Noice.