About 8 minutes to go when Gift put in a grubber kick in the north-east corner the Rooster got back into the field of play but then Manly tacklers put him back in goal. Checchin ruled a penalty. But from where I was sitting on the hill it looked like a clean one movement tackle. He hadn't yet got to ground & he hand't been lifted. Jamie complained but that really was game over for Manly. Was the referee correct on this?