Starling..??

[Sheikheagle]

childish post.!!

Saying you don't rate somebody (that gives 100% every week) without any reasoning is numbskullish!

 

[Snake]

I think Starling is a bench forward, that should come off the bench and work hard in the same vein as Mark Bryan and Joe Galuvao. I don't think he should start the match and set the tempo.

I agree with Dan, he is a solid defender in the middle, with good lateral movement. I just think he lacks the punch required to go with the really good packs in the early stages.

 

[cherry_poppins]

I think Starling is a bench forward, that should come off the bench and work hard in the same vein as Mark Bryan and Joe Galuvao. I don't think he should start the match and set the tempo.

I agree with Dan, he is a solid defender in the middle, with good lateral movement. I just think he lacks the punch required to go with the really good packs in the early stages.

A bench forward from the bench? Benchlyness

 

[IQofalimabean]

I rate Starling because he played well against the bulldogs pack in both games last year. His meters were similar to Lawrence also. Not an origin level forward, but one of the better props available for manly last year.

 

[Fluffy]

It was his first full season in the top grade last year and he went ok. Showed glimpses of what he can offer including a great game against he dogs, if he can be consistently like that then he will be a good run

 

[malroon]

After the wraps from 2013 do you think he under achieved .?

It was his first full season in the top grade last year and he went ok. Showed glimpses of what he can offer including a great game against he dogs, if he can be consistently like that then he will be a good run

 

[Wombat64]

Bring back Zorba. He'd give us some grunt up front. He has the goods. Trust me.

 

[Fluffy]

After the wraps from 2013 do you think he under achieved .?

**** no. He had played just 7 games when he came to us.

So looks like he is a keeper as you haven't put up anything to the contrary

 

[malroon]

should have read wraps from 2012


Haven't read anything yet too change my mind..

 

[mosto]

You also haven't given one criticism of his game. Just said you don't rate him. Personally, I think he's a solid first grader, nothing more, nothing less. Does his job and does it with minimal mistakes. Just doesn't do anything outstanding to put himself into that next level. Everyone available, he's in my 17.

 

[Dan]

should have read wraps from 2012


Haven't read anything yet too change my mind..

What have wraps from a previous year got to do with anything?

You've yet to say anything that validates your opinion as such I can only deduce you have an opinion but no reasoning for it and therefore it is impossible to change your mind with facts.

Borderline troll, 100% annoying

 

[Rex]

You've yet to say anything that validates your opinion as such I can only deduce you have an opinion but no reasoning for it and therefore it is impossible to change your mind with facts.

Borderline troll, 100% annoying

Annoying that someone provides an opinion here without explanation?

Why?

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Why do want an explanation? Isn't it enough that he said it was annoying?

 

[manlyfan76]

Annoying that someone provides an opinion here without explanation?

Why?

Because I think so

 

[Rex]

That's annoying

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Lol

 

[Dan]

no annoying that the onus is on us to prove something to him without knowing any parameters of that burden

 

[COMMANDER]

Smallest prop in the NRL. Big heart but is overmatched by every other prop going around, which defeats the point of being a prop.

 

[EagleFromMay1967]

Who ?