cherry and foz are the keys to our squad moving forward wether they stay or go. They are in demand and so they should be, but no way should we throw the house at them. They are a great halves pairing but they are a pairing. Its like trying to sell your house, convince your neigbour to sell at the same time and you could probably expect more , but how good are they alone.While they are important they have to be balanced with the cap. I just cant imagine we could spend more than about 800 k on each and still field a competitive side.especially while you have brett and jamie on big coin in the backs.
To be honest i dont even think they are 1 million players without the quality they have outside at there disposal. In the scheme of things do brett and jamie almost have as many try assists as the halves. And what about skivvy, a lot of work is currently done by other players atm. Do they actually deserve all the credit they get currently
Once jamie and brett are gone will they be as good with a baclkline full of matt utais and colin bests. We we even be able to retain the guthos, and turbos.
Keiran is gutsy, competitive, fealess and is developing, but a little one dimensional, doesnt kick that well. He has had considerable first grade and while still young isnt going to turn into a thurston . If he was we would have seen more of it by now.he is a great spirited player, and deserves a pay day but 1 million plus is unrealistic with this cap.He just doesnt own games consistently
Cherry probably has more potential, kicks well and looks like he may become a real game breaker . If i had to pick one id go for cherry as he will win games with class where foz wins them with passion and heart.i would pay more for cherry but i dont think we can afford to have both chewing up the cap. With origin and kiwi duties, injuries its too big a risk.
The dogs have shown how you can get there without gun halves but reliable steady halves.sometimes you have to take the emotion out of things and think long term. I would love them both at manly but i dont see why we would pay massive overs unless its about emotion
Not sure if theses rule changes about the wrestle will help there cause much either. All of a sudden robbie farrah becomes the playmaker again. Tooves would know a bit about that from history
To be honest i dont even think they are 1 million players without the quality they have outside at there disposal. In the scheme of things do brett and jamie almost have as many try assists as the halves. And what about skivvy, a lot of work is currently done by other players atm. Do they actually deserve all the credit they get currently
Once jamie and brett are gone will they be as good with a baclkline full of matt utais and colin bests. We we even be able to retain the guthos, and turbos.
Keiran is gutsy, competitive, fealess and is developing, but a little one dimensional, doesnt kick that well. He has had considerable first grade and while still young isnt going to turn into a thurston . If he was we would have seen more of it by now.he is a great spirited player, and deserves a pay day but 1 million plus is unrealistic with this cap.He just doesnt own games consistently
Cherry probably has more potential, kicks well and looks like he may become a real game breaker . If i had to pick one id go for cherry as he will win games with class where foz wins them with passion and heart.i would pay more for cherry but i dont think we can afford to have both chewing up the cap. With origin and kiwi duties, injuries its too big a risk.
The dogs have shown how you can get there without gun halves but reliable steady halves.sometimes you have to take the emotion out of things and think long term. I would love them both at manly but i dont see why we would pay massive overs unless its about emotion
Not sure if theses rule changes about the wrestle will help there cause much either. All of a sudden robbie farrah becomes the playmaker again. Tooves would know a bit about that from history
