1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Time for "Captain's Challenge" to be Introduced?

Discussion in 'Rugby League Forum' started by Aetna, Oct 11, 2013.

  1. Aetna

    Aetna Active Member

    222
    46
    Ratings:
    +56 /0
    Is it time for the NRL to introduce the "Captain's Challenge" similar to the cricket or tennis?

    My idea for the "Captain's Challenge" to be used succesfully & not to slow down the games momentum with too many stoppages is for a PENALTY to be given against any INCORRECT Captain's Challenge. The Captain's Challenge will be used only for strips, lost ball, high tackles, shoulder charge, blatten forward passes, tries, grounding the ball etc. The exeption maybe being for penalties for not being back 10 in the play the ball. This way you will not risk 2 points or another 6 tackles inside your quarter. Eg: If you know you didn't drop the ball but it was stripped or you didn't strip the ball but the opposition simply lost the ball it is worth using the Captain's Challenge.
     
  2. Jatz Crackers

    Jatz Crackers Moderator Staff Member

    9,139
    1,149
    Ratings:
    +1,248 /7
    I want less rules and more footy.

    KISS!
     
  3. Lord Eagleton

    Lord Eagleton Well-Known Member

    Ratings:
    +1,014 /29
    Except for when Shayne Hayne is on the field with a whistle in his mouth
     
  4. the mauler

    the mauler Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

    2,815
    1,155
    Ratings:
    +1,812 /27
    If the captains challenge was in place for GF Manly would be 13' premiers not the Rorters
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • faithful

      faithful Active Member

      175
      49
      Ratings:
      +50 /7
      Agree 100% was used in the Holden cup without any hickups first rule they bring in next season. I think the way it works they get 1 or 2 challeges per half and thats all you would need (surly the officials could only make 1 or 2 blues per half).
       
    • Aetna

      Aetna Active Member

      222
      46
      Ratings:
      +56 /0
      It's very important to penalize any INCORRECT Captain's Challenge so it can be used only for clear cut mistakes.
       
    • bob dylan

      bob dylan Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

      7,030
      2,084
      Junee
      Ratings:
      +4,857 /141
      So you have faith in the video refs??

      I reckon they are worse than the on field clowns by a factor of 10.

      Captains Challenge - No Thanks
       
    • Aetna

      Aetna Active Member

      222
      46
      Ratings:
      +56 /0
      It's not about the 50/50 calls but the clear cut mistakes. Video Ref's should not be getting clear cut decision wrong.
       
    • Fluffy

      Fluffy Well-Known Member

      18,599
      1,562
      Ratings:
      +4,673 /166
      its either that or allow the video ref to correct these clangers

      more and more often we are seeing shockers so something needs to be done
       
    • bob dylan

      bob dylan Well-Known Member Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

      7,030
      2,084
      Junee
      Ratings:
      +4,857 /141
      I am not talking about 50/50 calls.

      The video refs are the biggest joke of the lot.
       
    • globaleagle

      globaleagle Le ver vert va vers le verre vert! Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

      12,667
      5,068
      Ratings:
      +9,287 /71
      Buy me dinner first!


      Happy to trial captain's challenge. 2 ref's + 2 touchies+ 2 people in the video box can't get things right, so give it a go.
       
    • rosco

      rosco Active Member

      77
      48
      Ratings:
      +83 /4
      Captains Challenge has to be brought in. Use the same system trialled in Holden Cup. Only one unsuccessful Challenge per half so Captains don't challenge everything.
      Imagine if it was used in the GF. Hayne would have been a laughing stock when they overruled at least 6 of his calls. It would stop refs with a bias against one team ie Hayne giving so many dud calls as they wouldn't want to be continually challenged and caught out.
      As for the argument that it hold up play, so what! Would rather have a 30 sec break and get the right call.
      In the GF by the time they set the scrum after Jennings touch it had already been replayed so you could see that the call was wrong.
      Is the first rule that has to be changed in 2014. We need to get every piece of technology available to cut down the number of games being decided by dud refs. ie Hayne
       
      • Like Like x 2
      • Mark from Brisbane

        Mark from Brisbane Living the dream Premium Member

        17,492
        5,772
        Brisbane
        Ratings:
        +14,837 /288
        Think its worth trialling to see how it slows the game down , 1 per half BUT if they won the challenge they still have 1 to go , lose and none to the second half.

        Nothing to lose to see if it works.
         
      • MK Eagle

        MK Eagle Well-Known Member

        Ratings:
        +247 /0
        Refereeing decisions need to be cleared up & improved prior to finding more time wasting in the game.
        Some players stay down to get the penalty. At times theres a blatent hit & its not replayed , other times it is & theres a penalty for the lessor infringement???
        Video refs need to be able to rule on foward passes, its not Rugby Yawnion.
        There needs to be more consistency as in 1 ref lets players hang on in a tackle for an eternity & the next bloke blows the whistle after 2 seconds.
        Also noticed certain players , particularly the more popular ones , the refs joke with & talk respectfully & caution instead of just penalising them.
        This playing the ball off the mark is a pet hate & that JWH could be penalised 9/10 times for it & theres many others.....
        When it is over obviously off the mark, the ref call them back to play it??? My U11's get penalised for this....
        Need to get it right with what we already have before adding to it.
         
      • manlyfan76

        manlyfan76 Parra Trolls are the best. Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

        9,197
        2,612
        Anywhere but Parramatta
        Ratings:
        +6,329 /134
        In the 20's you can only challenge untill a the kick is taken. So if they kick for touch / goal then it's too late.
        I'm all for it.
         
      • NYEagle

        NYEagle Well-Known Member

        Ratings:
        +1,303 /75
        Captains challenge plus a GPS in the footballs would solve all problems.

        Works great in tennis,

        NYEagle
         
      • eagles2win

        eagles2win Well-Known Member

        Ratings:
        +494 /0
        I'm of the opinion if you can't have it at grass roots level why have it in top grade.

        As it is NRL is formula 1 rugby league.
         
      • Aetna

        Aetna Active Member

        222
        46
        Ratings:
        +56 /0
        I still think there should be a penalty awarded against the team which asks for a Captain's Challenge & looses it. This will make sure it isn't used willy nilly but only for when players know they were hard done by.
         
      • globaleagle

        globaleagle Le ver vert va vers le verre vert! Premium Member 2017 Tipping Competitor

        12,667
        5,068
        Ratings:
        +9,287 /71
        Unless you're Easts....then you lose a grand final.
         
      • sheridanstand78

        sheridanstand78 Well-Known Member

        3,050
        1,536
        Ratings:
        +3,595 /53
        I would like to see a captains call available for each half of football. It is also time to give video referees the chance to inform the on field referee of blatant forward passess and also ajudicate on calls where the ball goes dead either over the side line or dead ball line.

        The captains call would have earnt DCE a penalty when we led 18-8 for him being hit as Pearce was. Also the forward pass that was in the try that put Easts ahead.

        Come on ARLC get your bloody act together, the refs need help. It is the biggest blight on the game that the officials and not the players are determining results!!
         

      Share This Page