What’s your Signings preference

maxta

First Grader
yes I know right....just a signing or 2 as the same 3 teams seem to be building- now looking for more.
But here’s 2 options
1) Keep Green and add 2 good forwards.
2) Get 1 key playmaker with Green gone...plus 1 good forward.
Just keen to see preferences and why just out of interest.
 
Forwards win matches.
We have enough talent in DCE and Green to win games. Give me a Platinum level 2nd rower and a gun prop to add to this team and the backs will have a field day.
Would like Api to do more kicks from 9 to mix it up a bit.
Hastings Cullen are both young and could still become good halves / backups.
 
Forwards win matches.
We have enough talent in DCE and Green to win games. Give me a Platinum level 2nd rower and a gun prop to add to this team and the backs will have a field day.
Would like Api to do more kicks from 9 to mix it up a bit.
Hastings Cullen are both young and could still become good halves / backups.
You are certainly entitled to your opinion but I respectfully disagree.

Melbourne have debunked this theory for years now. When you have a good spine, the rest just falls into place. Forwards are just pawns in the game now. They are big bodies that are required to simply take the 3-4th and sometimes 5th hit up in a set after the modern winger has got a roll on in the first two rucks the set.

When you have good spine, you win the big games based on game management. Your hooker gets your forwards over the ad-line (a la Cameron Smith), your halves use backrowers on the edge to get the defence nervous and the fullback is your second option in attack. The halves guide the team around the park and tell the forwards what to do.

Felise Kaufusi is a classic example of how a good spine can make a backrower look like a world beater. He was a nobody before he started running off Cronk. Bryan Norrie was a career nobody before he started running off Cameron Smith.

The Dogs struggled because their spine was rubbish and a player like Klemmer looked like a reserve grader.

Sign Piss and move Green on. Green is adequate but Piss can take our left side to another level. He puts players into space on the edges, takes the line on, plays fast and direct, and knows how to lead a team around the park.

Of course a player like Thompson wouldn't hurt on the edges, but Pearce will transform our team more so than any forward could.
 
yes I know right....just a signing or 2 as the same 3 teams seem to be building- now looking for more.
But here’s 2 options
1) Keep Green and add 2 good forwards.
2) Get 1 key playmaker with Green gone...plus 1 good forward.
Just keen to see preferences and why just out of interest.
in a fantasy world i would like to poach one of joseph tapine /angus chricton for the backrow. paul vaughan/ david klemmer for the front row. bj leiluia / waqa blake for centre. jack bird/ nathan cleary for the halves. noteworthy mentions: coen hess, sio taukeiaho, jordan rapana, DWZ, tevita pangai jnr, JWH, cory harawira naera, jarrod wallace, asofa solomona, manu mau, shannon boyd, joel thompson, suli vunivalu, bryce cartwright,ava semeufagi, ryan james lol
 
I would rather Hastings fill Greens place and pickup 2 out of Crichton, Napa, Thompson, Klemmer perhaps.
Would still be happy if we got 1 of those and Pearce though too.
 
yes I know right....just a signing or 2 as the same 3 teams seem to be building- now looking for more.
But here’s 2 options
1) Keep Green and add 2 good forwards.
2) Get 1 key playmaker with Green gone...plus 1 good forward.
Just keen to see preferences and why just out of interest.
in the real world id prefer not to fork out for another almost 1mil player in Pearce. id be happy for green to stay for another year 2 max depending on options. possibly give carney a trial contract.thompson is a must in my opinion more important than pearce. id let darcy n brown walk and sign a proven prop forward like napa at this stage if available or try and poach wallace or RCG that wouldn't be demanding big dollars as yet. i believe we need a centre whether bj leiluia would come with percentage of his contract paid id say its a good option.
 
If we are taking an on contract player from st George, why wouldn't we just pay a bit more and get frizzell.
not a bad idea actually.. but youd think hed be on double what thompson is on i beluece on the market frizell could get 750k his that good
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 10 9 0 1 110 20
2 Warriors 10 8 0 2 5 18
3 Raiders 11 8 0 3 64 16
4 Storm 10 6 0 4 135 14
5 Sharks 11 7 0 4 70 14
6 Sea Eagles 10 5 0 5 38 12
7 Rabbitohs 11 6 0 5 -52 12
8 Cowboys 10 4 1 5 -32 11
9 Broncos 11 5 0 6 42 10
10 Dragons 10 4 0 6 -11 10
11 Roosters 10 4 0 6 -46 10
12 Tigers 11 5 0 6 -54 10
13 Panthers 10 3 1 6 -2 9
14 Dolphins 11 4 0 7 6 8
15 Knights 10 3 0 7 -74 8
16 Eels 10 3 0 7 -99 8
17 Titans 10 3 0 7 -100 8
Back
Top Bottom