Your Favourite 5 Manly player's EVER

[Spartan Eagle]

Myles, Brown, Field, Elgey and Croker

 

[Wombat64]

Myles, Brown, Field, Elgey and Croker

Love that list! Some "legends" in that one. In >50 years following Manly ...... Myles is my least favourite player ever! At least Lewis Brown and Croker seem like good guys.

 

[Briza]

Tough one, and in no particular order.

Krillich
Eadie
Cleal
Menzies
Toovey

 

[winnyason]

Cliffy
Toovs
Beaver
Snake
Stevie Matai

 

[Chip and Chase]

Given the impending public holiday that shall not be acknowledged, what about a top 5 favourite indigenous players

Cliffy
Cochrane
Georgie Boy
Rowdy
Rambo

Honorable mention to Andrew Walker and Paul Shaw

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Given the impending public holiday that shall not be acknowledged, what about a top 5 favourite indigenous players

Cliffy
Cochrane
Georgie Boy
Rowdy
Rambo

Honorable mention to Andrew Walker and Paul Shaw

I thought Michael Bani showed promise (just saw the clip of a try he scored over in one of the other threads) but he got a nasty injury and then seemed to disappear.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

And of course recently Joel Thompson wore the Sea Eagle jumper with distinction.
Hmm, @frank stokes might have a suggestion!

 

[Chip and Chase]

And of course recently Joel Thompson wore the Sea Eagle jumper with distinction.
Hmm, @frank stokes might have a suggestion!

It was only a top 5 - but yes those two and Bani. Also Brian Kelly, Jayden Hodges, Albert Torrens, & Ashley Alberts

 

[Chip and Chase]

And of course recently Joel Thompson wore the Sea Eagle jumper with distinction.
Hmm, @frank stokes might have a suggestion!

Actually Frank would make your top 5 for largest thighs.

 

[wombatgc]

Actually Frank would make your top 5 for largest thighs.

Frankie would definitely be in the top 5 thigh list for smaller blokes so too Phil Blake.