How many of these ex-players do you miss?

[swoop]

Dean Whare (Panthers)
Tony Williams (Bulldogs)
Darcy Lussick (Eels)
Daniel Harrison (Eels)
Michael Oldfield (Roosters)
Josh Drinkwater (Dragons)

I miss none of these players. Apart from Whare the rest look like park footballers since leaving.

 

[HappilyManly]

Im missing JoeeG 🙁

Deano is the only one I cheer for from the above

 

[lismore_fan]

Whose choice was it for them to leave? Manly's or the individual players?

 

[rambofan2013]

The club flicked them ALL for obvious reasons.

 

[Fluffy]

Having JWH in our squad right now would be handy

 

[MANLY4LIFE]

Deep down I think jwh hates that he had to leave as he always fires up against us,and as for those niff nuffs in that list maybe only whare

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Lussick would have been really good for us this year with the injury and suspension issues

 

[Dan]

Id have whare

 

[wombatgc]

Only one, and I still live in hope he'll come back...BEAVER!😉

 

[Filz]

T rex - form during 2011 then last year leading up to suspension was good after that went of the boil only had a few good games. Least wasnt as bad as hes playing at the dogs at the moment lol.
Dean whare - good handy utility who made kiwis playing for manly, but think hiku is doing a good job so far since hes been in for snake.
W.hopoate/JWH/Lussick - if the cap increase came in early wouldve like to think we kept these 3 who played in the sucesfull toyota cup teams with foz and dce as they were the future of the club incl lama tasi.

 

[bones]

If I could only pick one to have back, it would be T Rex.

 

[Shoe1]

As locals I miss oldfield and lussick. I miss lussick's little brother. Harrison would have helped our structure this year off the bench. I miss Harrison's little brother. Parra are **** but they took both talented little brothers off us.

 

[Top End Eagle]

If I could only pick one to have back, it would be T Rex.

Agree Bones. We have looked soft on the edges without his dominant defence and have let in far too many points that he used to stop with his (very much underrated) cover defence. Foran has also been shown up as ineffectual without defenders second guessing themselves about how to tackle Williams.

 

[Supesy]

I'd add another bloke to that list where we have missed his experience:

Robbo

I'd love to see him come back to Manly.

 

[tookey]

Des Hasler back as captain coach

---

If I could only pick one to have back, it would be T Rex.

You could have bought him on e-bay last week for $1 and then donated him to the club for free.

 

[anthonyb1965]

Whare has performed solidly for Penrith and really is all that is worth talking about.

I wouldn't have any of them back, I think we are better off without them!!!

 

[MK Eagle]

2 would be worthy & play a part with recent injuries & suspensions - Whare & Williams. We went pretty well in exchange though - would prefer both Lawrence & Horo over those 2 for half the money.....

 

[Masked Eagle]

If I could only pick one to have back, it would be T Rex.

Agree Bones. We have looked soft on the edges without his dominant defence and have let in far too many points that he used to stop with his (very much underrated) cover defence. Foran has also been shown up as ineffectual without defenders second guessing themselves about how to tackle Williams.

Can't say I agree with you there TEE. Our defence this year has arguably been a lot better than last years and the only problem with Forans attack is that he isn't getting enough of it, not that he isn't executing.