If you could wave a magic wand over this team... Who goes???

[missing_something]

If you could wave a magic wand over this team and replace just three players in this team at the end of the year who would you choose....

Orford
Kite
Matai

I think that would get us many $$$ to replace them with guys not past there prime.

 

[Fro]

1- 17.

with the exception of Rose and at times Foran

 

[DSM5]

Orford, Kite and Matai for me too.  Bad, soft, and stupid.

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Matai needs a rest. Lyon and Farrar in the centres.

 

[Nutzcraw]

All of them after today. Not a good player out there... actually Rose was good... but that's it.

Farrar had his worst game for us.

 

[TokyoEagle]

All of them after today. Not a good player out there... actually Rose was good... but that's it.

Farrar had his worst game for us.

He really didn't deserve to be the 1 to score that try, glad someone did though

 

[Fro]

hehe nobody deserved to score it, we didnt deserve to win 🙂

 

[niccipops]

I would definitely keep the Eagle mascot, he's got a lot of ticker.

 

[Dan]

Matai - In fact i will help him pack

Orford as bad as he can be, we would be worse without him, not because of his play just being there, if we can get a class replacement I would take him

Kite - Whatever King had the other year, Kite has it now, Mr soft prop.

Hard to disagree with the OP.

I dont know exactly where the problem is, its got a lot to do with attitude that is for sure

 

[kingyfan]

Perry is also soft.  He was pushed back more metres than he went forrwad today.  Kingy was on fire until he was injured. 

 

[Chip and Chase]

Does this magic wand of yours let you know who you are going to replace these 3 players with ?? No point sacking guys if there is no back up plan.

 

[Dan]

Does this magic wand of yours let you know who you are going to replace these 3 players with ?? No point sacking guys if there is no back up plan.

There is an obvious assumptiong, hence the "magic wand" that they would be replaced with others.

Let's rephrase his intended question

"Who is performing the worst?"

 

[Chip and Chase]

Obviously they will be replaced with someone, but my point is who ? No point punting Orford if we are getting Jason Ferris or Michael Monaghan back as his replacement.

 

[missing_something]

Does this magic wand of yours let you know who you are going to replace these 3 players with ?? No point sacking guys if there is no back up plan.

for the purpose of the exercise you can choose from these, players off contract 09

Finch - Carney - T.Smith

Broncos - Hunt, Lockyer, Taylor, Thaiday

Bulldogs - Maitua, Roberts, Ryan

Raiders - Graham, Learoyd-Lahrs, Withers

Sharks - Ross, Anderson

Titans - Bailey, Friend

Sea Eagles - Cuthbertson, Orford,

Storm - Hoffman, Cross

Knights - Hilder

Cowboys - Graham, Tronc, Scott

Eels - MoiMoi, Reddy

Panthers - Blair, Civoniceva

Rabbitohs - Greenfield, Sutton

Dragons - Creagh, B.Morris, Poore

Roosters - Minichiello, Roberts, Fitzgibbon, Myles, O'Mearly

Warriors - Mannering, Price, Witt

Tigers - Marshall, Morris, Payten

 

[Dan]

Mini has re-signed already, but

Carney I would take, he may have grown up and his kicking game is outstanding.
I would take Hoffman probably too
Roberts from the dogs would be worth buying too

**** there are plenty in that list I would take

 

[DVS Matt]

not sure how up to date that list is!

 

[Cletus]

Don't know about Matai but the other two can **** off. Perry has been **** this year as well, so he can share a cab with Orford and Kite to the airport.

 

[missing_something]

not sure how up to date that list is!

it's not at all - but neither is us personally getting rid of three players

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Farrar for Hayne
Kite for Petro
L'Estrange for Farah

 

[Moops]

What I can't understand is why guys like Kite/Perry/T-Rex, with all of their bulk, don't hit it up as hard as a guy like Moi Moi? Moi Moi is no bigger than these guys mentioned. Moi Moi would be a good swap for both Perry and Kite!!!