Pre-Game Manly v Dolphins [Round 15, 2023]

  • We had an issue with background services between march 10th and 15th or there about. This meant the payment services were not linking to automatic upgrades. If you paid for premium membership and are still seeing ads please let me know and the email you used against PayPal and I cam manually verify and upgrade your account.
  • We have been getting regular requests for users who have been locked out of their accounts because they have changed email adresses over the lifetime of their accounts. Please make sure the email address under your account is your current and correct email address in order to avoid this in the future. You can set your email address at https://silvertails.net/account/account-details
  • Wwe are currently experience some server issues which I am working through and hoping to resolve soon, Please bare with me whilst I work through making some changes and possible intermittent outages.
  • Apologies all our server was runing rogue. I managed to get us back to a point from 2:45 today though there is an attachment issue i will fix shortly. Things should be smooth now though
GAME ON! Head over to the Game Thread!

V

58 18
4 Pines Park
09 Jun 2023 08:00 PM

Team Lists


Status
Not open for further replies.

Waz13

Let’s all have a chew!
FMD Tuipolotu on the wing. Osaka guaranteed a hat trick. We name Vaega on the bench. In one game against Melbourne he showed more ticker and smarts than poor old Tui has over the past 18 months. Garrick in the centre. Again defensively quite naive. I would prefer Harper at centre and Garrick on teh wing. Dolphins will be targeting Tui/Garrick all night long. Has the feel of the Parra game where we had no problem scoring points but leaked points like a sieve.
You lost me at “prefer Harper at Centre”

That’s all.
 

davohan123

First Grader
Premium Member
Tipping Member
FMD Tuipolotu on the wing. Osaka guaranteed a hat trick. We name Vaega on the bench. In one game against Melbourne he showed more ticker and smarts than poor old Tui has over the past 18 months. Garrick in the centre. Again defensively quite naive. I would prefer Harper at centre and Garrick on teh wing. Dolphins will be targeting Tui/Garrick all night long. Has the feel of the Parra game where we had no problem scoring points but leaked points like a sieve.
You lost me when you said Harper at centre
 

Jethro

Star Trekkin' across the universe
Staff member
Premium Member
Tipping Member

Match Officials​

  • Referee: Gerard Sutton (not a fan of us)
  • Touch Judge: Peter Gough (last games referee)
  • Touch Judge: Darian Furner (one of last games Touchies)
  • Senior Review Official: Ashley Klein (not a fan of us)

Going by this weeks Match Officials List, we will be well and truly screwed over by them.
 

The Who

Journey Man

Match Officials​

  • Referee: Gerard Sutton (not a fan of us)
  • Touch Judge: Peter Gough (last games referee)
  • Touch Judge: Darian Furner (one of last games Touchies)
  • Senior Review Official: Ashley Klein (not a fan of us)

Going by this weeks Match Officials List, we will be well and truly screwed over by them.
So, which official is a fan?
 

Jethro

Star Trekkin' across the universe
Staff member
Premium Member
Tipping Member
So, which official is a fan?
Well, certainly not Gerard Sutton, Ashley Klein and Grant Atkins and going by the way that Peter Gough screwed us over last game when he was the referee, he isn't either.

I would just like a referee who is not bias and who can referee a game fairly and who can referee without going into a game with a cheat sheet to what to look out for with certain players, and to basically referee a game the way it should be refereed.

Who in the following list of Match Officials do you think would fall in that category?:

Adam Gee
Ashley Klein
Belinda Sharpe
Ben Cummins
Chris Butler
Chris Sutton
Darian Furner
Dave Munro
Drew Oultram
Gerard Sutton
Grant Atkins
Kasey Badger
Liam Kennedy
Matt Noyen
Peter Gough
Phil Henderson
Todd Smith
Wyatt Raymond
Ziggy Przeklasa-Adamski

Jared Maxwell - General Manager – Elite Officiating
 

mickqld

Sea Eagle forever
Tipping Member
Well, certainly not Gerard Sutton, Ashley Klein and Grant Atkins and going by the way that Peter Gough screwed us over last game when he was the referee, he isn't either.

I would just like a referee who is not bias and who can referee a game fairly and who can referee without going into a game with a cheat sheet to what to look out for with certain players, and to basically referee a game the way it should be refereed.

Who in the following list of Match Officials do you think would fall in that category?:

Adam Gee
Ashley Klein
Belinda Sharpe
Ben Cummins
Chris Butler
Chris Sutton
Darian Furner
Dave Munro
Drew Oultram
Gerard Sutton
Grant Atkins
Kasey Badger
Liam Kennedy
Matt Noyen
Peter Gough
Phil Henderson
Todd Smith
Wyatt Raymond
Ziggy Przeklasa-Adamski

Jared Maxwell - General Manager – Elite Officiating
They're all clowns.
 
1686109006385.png

We would have a better chance of winning if this Gerard was refereeing
 

LeonardCohen

Bencher
Well, certainly not Gerard Sutton, Ashley Klein and Grant Atkins and going by the way that Peter Gough screwed us over last game when he was the referee, he isn't either.

I would just like a referee who is not bias and who can referee a game fairly and who can referee without going into a game with a cheat sheet to what to look out for with certain players, and to basically referee a game the way it should be refereed.

Who in the following list of Match Officials do you think would fall in that category?:

Adam Gee
Ashley Klein
Belinda Sharpe
Ben Cummins
Chris Butler
Chris Sutton
Darian Furner
Dave Munro
Drew Oultram
Gerard Sutton
Grant Atkins
Kasey Badger
Liam Kennedy
Matt Noyen
Peter Gough
Phil Henderson
Todd Smith
Wyatt Raymond
Ziggy Przeklasa-Adamski

Jared Maxwell - General Manager – Elite Officiating
Adam Gee seems less of an ego maniac than some of the others so I’ll go with him. Obviously most of that list are not lead referees so I’m not including them in any comparison.

I kinda blame the NRL for the poor officiating. These referees don’t have any feel for the game because they’re not allowed to.
 

Rafferty

Mug punter
Heres our record under each ref, we have a 52% win rate under G Sutton.

RefereeGamesWLDWin %
ALEXANDER, Rob321-66.7%List
ALMOND, Neil642-66.7%List
ANNESLEY, Graham26188-69.2%List
ARCHER, Tony402713-67.5%List
ATKINS, Grant271413-51.9%List
BADGER, Gavin402218-55.0%List
BARNES, Barry17134-76.5%List
BARRY, Brian33--100.0%List
BISHOP, George1679-43.8%List
BRADLEY, Jack843150.0%List
BRADSTOCK, Barry76-185.7%List
BRAYBROOK, Denis1165-54.5%List
BROWN, Cliff372017-54.1%List
BRUYERES, Laurie412218153.7%List
BUTLER, Chris1586153.3%List
CASSIDY, Adam1-1-0.0%List
CECCHIN, Matt452024144.4%List
CLARK, Steve331418142.4%List
COOK, Gary261610-61.5%List
COOLEY, Phil21-150.0%List
COWLEY, Bert11--100.0%List
CUMMINS, Ben592732-45.8%List
DANZEY JNR, Jack241113-45.8%List
DAVIS, A1-1-0.0%List
DE LAS HERAS, Tony1284-66.7%List
DEVCICH, Adam15105-66.7%List
DEVINE, Bill11--100.0%List
DIMON, Cyril211-50.0%List
ELLISS, Phil11--100.0%List
ERICKSON, Fred231010343.5%List
FILMER, Peter22--100.0%List
GEE, Adam301317-43.3%List
GOCHER, John432912267.4%List
GOLDSWORTHY, Barry211-50.0%List
GOUGH, Peter954-55.6%List
GRANT, Brian935133.3%List
HAINES, Phil1293-75.0%List
HALLWOOD, G1-1-0.0%List
HAMPSTEAD, Sean301713-56.7%List
HARRIGAN, Bill381919-50.0%List
HARRIS, Jack624-33.3%List
HARTLEY, Greg382311460.5%List
HAYNE, Shayne593919166.1%List
HENDERSON, Phil532-60.0%List
HEWITT, Matt752-71.4%List
HOLMAN, Keith944144.4%List
HUMPHREYS, Richie55--100.0%List
JACOBSON, Jack1-1-0.0%List
JADWAT, Moghseen642-66.7%List
JAMES, Chris22139-59.1%List
JAY, David1-1-0.0%List
JEFFES, Kelvin19152278.9%List
KELLAHAN, George11--100.0%List
KELLY, Bill532-60.0%List
KELLY, Jack422-50.0%List
KELLY, Tony1091-90.0%List
KENNEDY, Liam312-33.3%List
KEOUGH, Kevin1--10.0%List
KLEIN, Ashley351718-48.6%List
KONNECKE, A11--100.0%List
LANCASHIRE, Don523-40.0%List
LANE, George1-1-0.0%List
LANGTON, Carl321-66.7%List
LAWLER, Darcy552430143.6%List
LAWRENCE, Rod11--100.0%List
LEWIS, Mick211-50.0%List
LYONS, Steve16106-62.5%List
McBLANE, Paul1073-70.0%List
McCALLUM, Greg432617-60.5%List
McMAHON JNR, Tom1449128.6%List
McMILLAN, R1-1-0.0%List
MacDONALD, Don15105-66.7%List
MAKSOUD, Tony11--100.0%List
MANDER, Tim21812138.1%List
MANSON, David31218267.7%List
MAXWELL, Jared402416-60.0%List
MORRIS, Gavin945-44.4%List
MUNRO, David844-50.0%List
NEVILLE, Arthur514-20.0%List
NICHOLSON, Dudley22--100.0%List
NOYEN, Matt835-37.5%List
O'BRIEN, Jack271412151.9%List
O'DONNELL, Giles632150.0%List
O'DONNELL, Ray642-66.7%List
OATEN, Mark33--100.0%List
OXFORD, Aub271115140.7%List
PAGE, Keith22138159.1%List
PARKINSON, Keith742157.1%List
PARNABY, Ian22--100.0%List
PEARCE, Col612139134.4%List
PERENARA, Henry271314-48.1%List
PERRY, Albert1-1-0.0%List
PHILLIPS, Luke321-66.7%List
PRZEKLASA-ADAMSKI, Zbignew954-55.6%List
RASCAGNERES, Julien11--100.0%List
REYNOLDS, Gavin211011-47.6%List
ROBERTS, Kevin442321-52.3%List
ROBINSON, Jason21138-61.9%List
ROBY, Tim743-57.1%List
SAMUELSON, Les1064-60.0%List
SHARPE, Belinda11--100.0%List
SHINER, Austin954-55.6%List
SHORTALL, Alan261412-53.8%List
SIMPKINS, Paul241113-45.8%List
SMITH, Russell633-50.0%List
SMITH, Todd321-66.7%List
SMYTH, Ray6-6-0.0%List
SPAGARINO, Denis211-50.0%List
STONE, Jon1046-40.0%List
STONE, Mick332112-63.6%List
SUTTON, Bernard431-75.0%List
SUTTON, Chris211011-47.6%List
SUTTON, Gerard462421152.2%List
SUTTOR, Brett1156-45.5%List
THOMPSON, Billy11--100.0%List
TURNELL, Col22--100.0%List
WALES JR, Baden541-80.0%List
WALSH, Frank11--100.0%List
WARD, Chris1485157.1%List
WARD, Eddie351816151.4%List
WEEKES, Martin1257-41.7%List
WEEKS, Geoff44--100.0%List
WEST, Graeme15123-80.0%List
WILLIAMS, Les642-66.7%List
Total157610128023654.7%
 

Bradza

Bencher
Tipping Member
I like the team that we have named for Friday night’s game although I’d feel a whole lot better if Jake was fit to play. The Dolphins side named still looks like it would be competitive.

I bought two tickets in the Bob Fulton stand. It will be my first time checking this part of the ground out and I’m hoping to celebrate it with a good win
You’ll love it, so long as we don’t play like the Sharks/Titans games!
 

Tragic Eagle

Tragic
Premium Member
Tipping Member
If Tui bombs another try I’m going to lose my sh*t
He focuses on the defender coming across and then causes the collision rather than going into the air towards the corner. I saw the team doing that training landing on mats indoors during the off season. I hope they have done more work with him.
 

Eagle 1

First Grader
Heres our record under each ref, we have a 52% win rate under G Sutton.

RefereeGamesWLDWin %
ALEXANDER, Rob321-66.7%List
ALMOND, Neil642-66.7%List
ANNESLEY, Graham26188-69.2%List
ARCHER, Tony402713-67.5%List
ATKINS, Grant271413-51.9%List
BADGER, Gavin402218-55.0%List
BARNES, Barry17134-76.5%List
BARRY, Brian33--100.0%List
BISHOP, George1679-43.8%List
BRADLEY, Jack843150.0%List
BRADSTOCK, Barry76-185.7%List
BRAYBROOK, Denis1165-54.5%List
BROWN, Cliff372017-54.1%List
BRUYERES, Laurie412218153.7%List
BUTLER, Chris1586153.3%List
CASSIDY, Adam1-1-0.0%List
CECCHIN, Matt452024144.4%List
CLARK, Steve331418142.4%List
COOK, Gary261610-61.5%List
COOLEY, Phil21-150.0%List
COWLEY, Bert11--100.0%List
CUMMINS, Ben592732-45.8%List
DANZEY JNR, Jack241113-45.8%List
DAVIS, A1-1-0.0%List
DE LAS HERAS, Tony1284-66.7%List
DEVCICH, Adam15105-66.7%List
DEVINE, Bill11--100.0%List
DIMON, Cyril211-50.0%List
ELLISS, Phil11--100.0%List
ERICKSON, Fred231010343.5%List
FILMER, Peter22--100.0%List
GEE, Adam301317-43.3%List
GOCHER, John432912267.4%List
GOLDSWORTHY, Barry211-50.0%List
GOUGH, Peter954-55.6%List
GRANT, Brian935133.3%List
HAINES, Phil1293-75.0%List
HALLWOOD, G1-1-0.0%List
HAMPSTEAD, Sean301713-56.7%List
HARRIGAN, Bill381919-50.0%List
HARRIS, Jack624-33.3%List
HARTLEY, Greg382311460.5%List
HAYNE, Shayne593919166.1%List
HENDERSON, Phil532-60.0%List
HEWITT, Matt752-71.4%List
HOLMAN, Keith944144.4%List
HUMPHREYS, Richie55--100.0%List
JACOBSON, Jack1-1-0.0%List
JADWAT, Moghseen642-66.7%List
JAMES, Chris22139-59.1%List
JAY, David1-1-0.0%List
JEFFES, Kelvin19152278.9%List
KELLAHAN, George11--100.0%List
KELLY, Bill532-60.0%List
KELLY, Jack422-50.0%List
KELLY, Tony1091-90.0%List
KENNEDY, Liam312-33.3%List
KEOUGH, Kevin1--10.0%List
KLEIN, Ashley351718-48.6%List
KONNECKE, A11--100.0%List
LANCASHIRE, Don523-40.0%List
LANE, George1-1-0.0%List
LANGTON, Carl321-66.7%List
LAWLER, Darcy552430143.6%List
LAWRENCE, Rod11--100.0%List
LEWIS, Mick211-50.0%List
LYONS, Steve16106-62.5%List
McBLANE, Paul1073-70.0%List
McCALLUM, Greg432617-60.5%List
McMAHON JNR, Tom1449128.6%List
McMILLAN, R1-1-0.0%List
MacDONALD, Don15105-66.7%List
MAKSOUD, Tony11--100.0%List
MANDER, Tim21812138.1%List
MANSON, David31218267.7%List
MAXWELL, Jared402416-60.0%List
MORRIS, Gavin945-44.4%List
MUNRO, David844-50.0%List
NEVILLE, Arthur514-20.0%List
NICHOLSON, Dudley22--100.0%List
NOYEN, Matt835-37.5%List
O'BRIEN, Jack271412151.9%List
O'DONNELL, Giles632150.0%List
O'DONNELL, Ray642-66.7%List
OATEN, Mark33--100.0%List
OXFORD, Aub271115140.7%List
PAGE, Keith22138159.1%List
PARKINSON, Keith742157.1%List
PARNABY, Ian22--100.0%List
PEARCE, Col612139134.4%List
PERENARA, Henry271314-48.1%List
PERRY, Albert1-1-0.0%List
PHILLIPS, Luke321-66.7%List
PRZEKLASA-ADAMSKI, Zbignew954-55.6%List
RASCAGNERES, Julien11--100.0%List
REYNOLDS, Gavin211011-47.6%List
ROBERTS, Kevin442321-52.3%List
ROBINSON, Jason21138-61.9%List
ROBY, Tim743-57.1%List
SAMUELSON, Les1064-60.0%List
SHARPE, Belinda11--100.0%List
SHINER, Austin954-55.6%List
SHORTALL, Alan261412-53.8%List
SIMPKINS, Paul241113-45.8%List
SMITH, Russell633-50.0%List
SMITH, Todd321-66.7%List
SMYTH, Ray6-6-0.0%List
SPAGARINO, Denis211-50.0%List
STONE, Jon1046-40.0%List
STONE, Mick332112-63.6%List
SUTTON, Bernard431-75.0%List
SUTTON, Chris211011-47.6%List
SUTTON, Gerard462421152.2%List
SUTTOR, Brett1156-45.5%List
THOMPSON, Billy11--100.0%List
TURNELL, Col22--100.0%List
WALES JR, Baden541-80.0%List
WALSH, Frank11--100.0%List
WARD, Chris1485157.1%List
WARD, Eddie351816151.4%List
WEEKES, Martin1257-41.7%List
WEEKS, Geoff44--100.0%List
WEST, Graeme15123-80.0%List
WILLIAMS, Les642-66.7%List
Total157610128023654.7%
The Chechin howeller againt Orford v the GC was the worst. Cost us the game, i was there that day, took me ages to get over it
 

globaleagle

01100111 01100101
Staff member
Premium Member
Tipping Member
Heres our record under each ref, we have a 52% win rate under G Sutton.

RefereeGamesWLDWin %
ALEXANDER, Rob321-66.7%List
ALMOND, Neil642-66.7%List
ANNESLEY, Graham26188-69.2%List
ARCHER, Tony402713-67.5%List
ATKINS, Grant271413-51.9%List
BADGER, Gavin402218-55.0%List
BARNES, Barry17134-76.5%List
BARRY, Brian33--100.0%List
BISHOP, George1679-43.8%List
BRADLEY, Jack843150.0%List
BRADSTOCK, Barry76-185.7%List
BRAYBROOK, Denis1165-54.5%List
BROWN, Cliff372017-54.1%List
BRUYERES, Laurie412218153.7%List
BUTLER, Chris1586153.3%List
CASSIDY, Adam1-1-0.0%List
CECCHIN, Matt452024144.4%List
CLARK, Steve331418142.4%List
COOK, Gary261610-61.5%List
COOLEY, Phil21-150.0%List
COWLEY, Bert11--100.0%List
CUMMINS, Ben592732-45.8%List
DANZEY JNR, Jack241113-45.8%List
DAVIS, A1-1-0.0%List
DE LAS HERAS, Tony1284-66.7%List
DEVCICH, Adam15105-66.7%List
DEVINE, Bill11--100.0%List
DIMON, Cyril211-50.0%List
ELLISS, Phil11--100.0%List
ERICKSON, Fred231010343.5%List
FILMER, Peter22--100.0%List
GEE, Adam301317-43.3%List
GOCHER, John432912267.4%List
GOLDSWORTHY, Barry211-50.0%List
GOUGH, Peter954-55.6%List
GRANT, Brian935133.3%List
HAINES, Phil1293-75.0%List
HALLWOOD, G1-1-0.0%List
HAMPSTEAD, Sean301713-56.7%List
HARRIGAN, Bill381919-50.0%List
HARRIS, Jack624-33.3%List
HARTLEY, Greg382311460.5%List
HAYNE, Shayne593919166.1%List
HENDERSON, Phil532-60.0%List
HEWITT, Matt752-71.4%List
HOLMAN, Keith944144.4%List
HUMPHREYS, Richie55--100.0%List
JACOBSON, Jack1-1-0.0%List
JADWAT, Moghseen642-66.7%List
JAMES, Chris22139-59.1%List
JAY, David1-1-0.0%List
JEFFES, Kelvin19152278.9%List
KELLAHAN, George11--100.0%List
KELLY, Bill532-60.0%List
KELLY, Jack422-50.0%List
KELLY, Tony1091-90.0%List
KENNEDY, Liam312-33.3%List
KEOUGH, Kevin1--10.0%List
KLEIN, Ashley351718-48.6%List
KONNECKE, A11--100.0%List
LANCASHIRE, Don523-40.0%List
LANE, George1-1-0.0%List
LANGTON, Carl321-66.7%List
LAWLER, Darcy552430143.6%List
LAWRENCE, Rod11--100.0%List
LEWIS, Mick211-50.0%List
LYONS, Steve16106-62.5%List
McBLANE, Paul1073-70.0%List
McCALLUM, Greg432617-60.5%List
McMAHON JNR, Tom1449128.6%List
McMILLAN, R1-1-0.0%List
MacDONALD, Don15105-66.7%List
MAKSOUD, Tony11--100.0%List
MANDER, Tim21812138.1%List
MANSON, David31218267.7%List
MAXWELL, Jared402416-60.0%List
MORRIS, Gavin945-44.4%List
MUNRO, David844-50.0%List
NEVILLE, Arthur514-20.0%List
NICHOLSON, Dudley22--100.0%List
NOYEN, Matt835-37.5%List
O'BRIEN, Jack271412151.9%List
O'DONNELL, Giles632150.0%List
O'DONNELL, Ray642-66.7%List
OATEN, Mark33--100.0%List
OXFORD, Aub271115140.7%List
PAGE, Keith22138159.1%List
PARKINSON, Keith742157.1%List
PARNABY, Ian22--100.0%List
PEARCE, Col612139134.4%List
PERENARA, Henry271314-48.1%List
PERRY, Albert1-1-0.0%List
PHILLIPS, Luke321-66.7%List
PRZEKLASA-ADAMSKI, Zbignew954-55.6%List
RASCAGNERES, Julien11--100.0%List
REYNOLDS, Gavin211011-47.6%List
ROBERTS, Kevin442321-52.3%List
ROBINSON, Jason21138-61.9%List
ROBY, Tim743-57.1%List
SAMUELSON, Les1064-60.0%List
SHARPE, Belinda11--100.0%List
SHINER, Austin954-55.6%List
SHORTALL, Alan261412-53.8%List
SIMPKINS, Paul241113-45.8%List
SMITH, Russell633-50.0%List
SMITH, Todd321-66.7%List
SMYTH, Ray6-6-0.0%List
SPAGARINO, Denis211-50.0%List
STONE, Jon1046-40.0%List
STONE, Mick332112-63.6%List
SUTTON, Bernard431-75.0%List
SUTTON, Chris211011-47.6%List
SUTTON, Gerard462421152.2%List
SUTTOR, Brett1156-45.5%List
THOMPSON, Billy11--100.0%List
TURNELL, Col22--100.0%List
WALES JR, Baden541-80.0%List
WALSH, Frank11--100.0%List
WARD, Chris1485157.1%List
WARD, Eddie351816151.4%List
WEEKES, Martin1257-41.7%List
WEEKS, Geoff44--100.0%List
WEST, Graeme15123-80.0%List
WILLIAMS, Les642-66.7%List
Total157610128023654.7%

50% of that was after the bunker was introduced!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Team P W L PD Pts
16 13 3 125 32
16 11 5 116 28
17 11 6 225 26
17 11 6 125 26
16 9 7 65 24
16 9 7 48 24
17 9 7 67 23
17 9 8 1 22
17 9 8 -56 22
17 8 9 -81 20
16 7 9 -93 20
17 7 9 -32 19
17 7 10 9 18
16 6 10 -59 18
16 6 10 -104 18
17 4 13 -153 12
17 4 13 -203 12
Back
Top Bottom