Question re: Koroisou

[fLIP]

It has to be a penalty, he went beyond horizontal because of the tackle, intent or not.

The problem is the devious coaches of the competition will see an opportunity to exploit the call and we'll see storm, i mean, some players doing cartwheels in every tackle from here on in.

 

[MissKate]

Great low shot but he ended up in a dangerous position and as the rules stand it was a penalty every day of the week.

However, in the raiders/ cowgirls game someone was tackled which went more over the horizontal - no penalty

 

[Garts]

However, in the raiders/ cowgirls game someone was tackled which went more over the horizontal - no penalty

Are you surprised? Consistency is not their strongest quality. They get rulings inconsistent in the same game let alone different ones.

 

[Harvies elbow]

Of course it's a penalty.

The tackle was performed by a Manly player wasn't it?
I'll be looking out for refs interpretations in games involving other teams in future.
Badge had a sh*t game yesterday.
He's better than that.

 

[Shoe1]

Mate, if we lost a GF or something like that honestly, I think I'd end up in the coronary hospital !!
The whole thing is, did API put him in that dangerous position, or was it that both parties colliding the way they did that contributed to the falling momentum?

Little known fact. Biscuits Stanton was admitted to hospital with a mild coronary after the 97 grand final.