Sack Spoony Siebold

[Mark from Brisbane]

I wish we'd kept Flanagan but if Siebold gets sacked the only coach I'd want, of the realistic options, is Arthur.

Who led Parramatta to a spoon and almost zero success ??

 

[BOZO]

Who led Parramatta to a spoon and almost zero success ??

Both Seibold and Arthurs teams got the spoon
The almost zero successful Arthur go his team into a Grand final
What does that make Seibold ?

 

[TJ55]

Both Seibold and Arthurs teams got the spoon
The almost zero successful Arthur go his team into a Grand final
What does that make Seibold ?

Bring back Tooves

 

[eaglebuzz]

Who led Parramatta to a spoon and almost zero success ??

He also led them to a GF. He can coach, Parramatta is just a basket case of a club.

 

[The '47ers]

Bring back Tooves

No thanks

 

[LeonardCohen]

There’s more black and white arguments in the face of shades of grey. It’s not the coach OR the players, it’s the coach AND the players. It’s a relationship that requires both parties to do their job well to be successful. It’s never just one or the other when things fail. There are too many variables for that.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Let’s see how the rest of the season unfolds. There is still time for salvation.

 

[eaglebuzz]

I think we have gone backwards a bit this with regards to our ability to wish without Turbo. Unfortunately we will need him to stay fit to challenge for the top 4. Paseka's injury was a big factor in that too.

But if you take the best prop and first choice fullback out of any side they probably drop out of the top 4.

 

[Ben]

Huh? You specifically said you wanted Burgess.

Goes to show the value of weight in his comments

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Why are we sacking him this week? We don't even have a game!
(and last week we beat the 4 time defending premiers)

 

[Disco]

Let’s see how the rest of the season unfolds. There is still time for salvation.

Yeah we are equal 5th on points.

So much panic

 

[Pete W]

He also led them to a GF. He can coach, Parramatta is just a basket case of a club.

Unfortunately, so are we

 

[Scorpio]

He also led them to a GF. He can coach, Parramatta is just a basket case of a club.

He also had 10 and a half seasons as head coach, a GF appearance in year 9, with multiple turnovers of the player roster. How long would you be prepared to give him as Manly coach?

 

[Bloke on the hill]

True, but if the coach fails to drop players then one must assume either they are doing what he wants or he is a fool for a coach. Which one is it for SeiFool?

I clearly remember Des would never change a manly team win lose or draw & they lost alot.
At GC he's not changing things AND they sit at 14th atm.

 

[Bloke on the hill]

Here's a curve ball thought...some teams have better players than other teams & the coach isn't always the issue.
BTW, I don't know Seibs & have never met him.

 

[BOZO]

Here's a curve ball thought...some teams have better players than other teams & the coach isn't always the issue.
BTW, I don't know Seibs & have never met him.

You do not have to meet a coach to see what type of a coach he is
His results speak for them selves feathered friend