Schuster or Foran for 5/8th 2022

[Mark from Brisbane]

I wish everyone would get back on topic… so where do you rate Garrick compared to the other wingers in the comp?

Up there , maybe not the power of some but I wouldn’t choose too many others over him!!

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

I wish everyone would get back on topic… so where do you rate Garrick compared to the other wingers in the comp?

How about reigning Dally M Winger of the Year, along with To'o.

 

[HK_Eagle]

How about reigning Dally M Winger of the Year, along with To'o.

How about busting a tackle moving forward…just saying.

 

[XV-1]

The time is right for Foran to step aside in the 2nd half of this season and let Schuster prosper and fulfil his partnership with Burbo.

Go Manly!!

 

[XV-1]

Pretty simple. We cannot beat any top 8 team with Foran in the team.

Bring Schuster into 5/8th and Foran to the bench.

 

[Ryan]

Pretty simple. We cannot beat any top 8 team with Foran in the team.

Bring Schuster into 5/8th and Foran to the bench.

Mate, respect your opinion on that, but I'd also be looking at getting a proper number 9 in the team. It's been three years now, the experiment with Croker has failed. Let Croker play his specialist position.

We need some ex factor out of dummy half. Some explosive speed and momentum. A hooker that will get us on a roll.

Until that happens, we'll keep being fodder / roadkill to any decent team.

 

[XV-1]

Mate, respect your opinion on that, but I'd also be looking at getting a proper number 9 in the team. It's been three years now, the experiment with Croker has failed. Let Croker play his specialist position.

We need some ex factor out of dummy half. Some explosive speed and momentum. A hooker that will get us on a roll.

Until that happens, we'll keep being fodder / roadkill to any decent team.

I agree. BUT we don't have a proper 9.
We do have a proper 5/8th.

Foran is leaving - put him on the bench to support Croker and get the schiit beaten out of him b4 he goes to Titans.

That has got to be better than what we have now..

 

[Ryan]

I agree. BUT we don't have a proper 9.
We do have a proper 5/8th.

Foran is leaving - put him on the bench to support Croker and get the schiit beaten out of him b4 he goes to Titans.

Honestly, I'd make Schuster lock (he's WAY too overweight/slow for 5/8). He does the same things as a 5/8. We need to get Jake out of the 13 jumper - he's WAY too immobile and slow - he needs to play prop (he's quite similar to Tolman).

If you want to blood someone let Weekes have a run at 6.

 

[JenEagle]

Maybe segeyaro to bench hooker

 

[Disco]

Mate, respect your opinion on that, but I'd also be looking at getting a proper number 9 in the team. It's been three years now, the experiment with Croker has failed. Let Croker play his specialist position.

We need some ex factor out of dummy half. Some explosive speed and momentum. A hooker that will get us on a roll.

Until that happens, we'll keep being fodder / roadkill to any decent team.

Funny thing is, I reckon Foran would have made a fantastic number nine.

Ah well guess we will never find out

 

[XV-1]

This has aged well.

As I have been saying since his debut.

Give the kid a chance and he will succeed and be our future.

 

[Tragic Eagle]

Funny thing is, I reckon Foran would have made a fantastic number nine.

Ah well guess we will never find out

Des had that opportunity but didn’t use it.

 

[XV-1]

Des had that opportunity but didn’t use it.

That was the problem with Des. Stuck in his ways.
He has plenty of opportunities and seemingly only took them after injuries forced his hand.