I will preface this that I starting actively supporting Manly in 1976.
The players below are my favourites.
Graham Eadie, my hero when I was a kid.
Brett Stewart, one of our greatest ever players.
Jamie Lyon, his calmness and coolness made him an amazing captain.
Steve Menzies, arguable our greatest local junior, try machine, scored them for fun
Cliffy Lyons, one of the most naturally gifted players to ever wear the maroon and white, and the combination he had with Menzies was a match winner.