Burbo

[Bird of Prey]

So Ben gets played out of position and now he is sh1t again?

ok...some fck clueless people on here.

Ben is a long way short of a first grade player in the forwards or the backs , this is why we are **** at the moment making excuses for crap players isn’t a way forward harsh decisions must be made.

 

[Rocky]

Ben is a long way short of a first grade player in the forwards or the backs , this is why we are **** at the moment making excuses for crap players isn’t a way forward harsh decisions must be made.

Noted - that's changed my mind

 

[bob dylan]

Seriously, he was burned by a very class player who has played 23 Origin games and 6 games for Australia, while playing out of position. He has only been picked to play centre 5 times in his 59 matches. career.

He was playing both inside and outside weak defenders and to Newcastles credit they hammered that side.

Dont get me wrong I am no fanboy but he does a decent job and for the money he'd be on is an ideal bench player in a strong team.

 

[susan]

Seriously, he was burned by a very class player who has played 23 Origin games and 6 games for Australia, while playing out of position. He has only been picked to play centre 5 times in his 59 matches. career.

He was playing both inside and outside weak defenders and to Newcastles credit they hammered that side.

Dont get me wrong I am no fanboy but he does a decent job and for the money he'd be on is an ideal bench player in a strong team.

Yep. He’s an adequate bench forward.Couid become a consistent first grade bench pig but carrying a second rower and hooker on the bench is not really a great option.Got a role to play maybe but we need a classy left side edge and top flight prop. Get those and luck with injury then top 4 isn’t out of a question.

 

[Rafferty]

I’ve been a critic for Burbo’s for a while but he did have a strong few weeks before last night so I’m not going to hold it against him. Everyone but Seibold knows it’s been a disaster every time he’s moved to the centres and that’s what happened last night, absolutely fried by 34 year old Dane Gagai. Ironically we were the ones taking advantage of a centre mismatch in the first half with Garrick on Schiller.

Bigger issue is the only other second rower in the squad being Waddell. You lose one back early and now this bloke is playing nearly a full game on the edge. Have him defending next to Burbo and even the worst teams in the comp can exploit that, as we saw the Knights do last night. Give Chee Kam a run or sign someone else.

Fair assessment and the right call….

 

[Rafferty]

So Ben gets played out of position and now he is sh1t again?

ok...some fck clueless people on here.

The clueless one is Seibs……

 

[Rocky]

The clueless one is Seibs……

I suspect that given Saab and Turbo were missing then he didn't trust any of the outside backs in reggies to step up.

This isn't pointed at you, but many on here crucified Seibold for having Clayton on the bench and him not being used a month or so ago.

But yes Burbo to centre is not an option

 

[Rafferty]

I suspect that given Saab and Turbo were missing then he didn't trust any of the outside backs in reggies to step up.

This isn't pointed at you, but many on here crucified Seibold for having Clayton on the bench and him not being used a month or so ago.

But yes Burbo to centre is not an option

Cheers and I agree, but it goes way deeper than that, we were up 16 nil at half time, no excusses, that was with our missing players, Lehi and all things being equal, the knights were in a far worse off place than us, if we had a coach with any idea and ability to steer us home from that position, we wouldn’t be having these discussions, we’d all be happy with a win and 2 points.

I could write a list of Seibs misses on last night, but most of them have been pointed out already and to be honest, l’m not sure it’s worth it, he has been exposed over and over now and has lost me from this point forward, until or if he proves otherwise, which I won’t be holding my breath on.