Dirty at RLW!

[Zep]

So they have there annual poll of best players, overrated player etc,

Brent Kite is in the Overated list. So he isn't have the best season, he had to bury his father at the beginning of the year. Such lame asses.

For best player of the year, i went with Thurston, only because Inglis has patches, Falou falls over people when there back is turned and Brett Stewart isn't on the list.

 

[Harmless27]

Where was Kingy in the player of the year poll!!!!!!

Did anyone see NRL Tactics last night - Watmough is second highest in the league for tackle busts (the only forward in the top 5) witha round 80-odd tackle busts.  All the others are fullbacks and wingers - next forward on the list is more than 20 tacklebusts behind him!  What a weapon!

Over-rated player - BENJI MARSHALL, Kurt Gidley, Paul Gallen, and Mitchel Pearce for me!

 

[Dan]

Gidley has to be the most over rated

 

[Jethro]

Hey Zep (or anybody), who else is on the list in RLW for the most overrated player & best players?

 

[Fro]

Matt Orford

 

[clontaago]

Zep its not RLW you should be upset at.

Isnt that the poll where current players vote?

 

[Dan]

the fact that kite's father died, although sad, has nothing to do with the fact that on the way he is playing currently he is over rated really

 

[gomanly]

Kurt Gidley is the most over rated player in the world! His woeful origin performance shows that, and the fact he said he was ready to be the captain of the blues shows how deluded the ****kwit is!

 

[Fro]

he didnt appoint himself captain Fulton.

 

[lsz]

Re kite I think there is a fair difference between over rated and in a form slump.

Clive Churchill medallist one year over-rated the next?

If you look at the stats he is down on Metres but up on tackles

Kite 2008 2009
Mtrs 126.1 101.8
Tcks 23.4 26.6
Runs 14.9 13.2


As for Gidley his stats do not lie

Player App Try Gls Pts Mins LB LBA TryA Off TBrk Mins Runs Mtrs Tcks Miss Inef KR KRM Runs Mtrs Tcks Miss Inef KR KRM Kicks Mtrs 40/20 Err Pen
09 13 1 44 92 1027 3 8 4 21 63 79 19.5 170.7 7.2 1.5 0.5 5.5 58 254 2219 94 19 7 72 754 16 298 0 22 4
08 20 9 57 150 1598 12 8 6 23 106 79.9 19.8 178.2 8 1.4 0.7 5 57.8 396 3563 161 29 14 99 1155 55 1490 0 24 13

 

[eggson]

I read a news article about players not commenting on the overrated category this year.  Sign of the times? 

 

[blitzkrieg]

Most overated = Pearce. A name will only get you so far, how did he ever play SOO?!

 

[Brookvale]

Gidley is most over rated

I think Mitchell Pearce is a star in the making, but he is playing behind a bust team and second fiddle to that model Anastas.


Best Players are origin reps Hayne, Inglis, THurston & Choc.