Hales Gone

[mave]

So what about Souths coming 3rd in 2018?

Ummmm, everyone knows that was really Madges side......oh wait

 

[Cochrane]

So what about Souths coming 3rd in 2018?

Lack of reefs, clear sailing, favourable tides, no leaks.

 

[XV-1]

So what about Souths coming 3rd in 2018?

Out in straight sets and rot has continued ever since.
Enjoy Maccas with Seibold

 

[blacktown eagle]

Out in straight sets and rot has continued ever since.
Enjoy Maccas with Seibold

So by your logic the broncos team that almost went all the way in 23 that consisted of the nucleus that Siebold put together was his doing, just like “the rot that has continued ever since” at souths. Am I right?

 

[skull61]

Now for Dymock

 

[Brookie1973]

Now for Dymock

Promotion?

 

[XV-1]

So by your logic the broncos team that almost went all the way in 23 that consisted of the nucleus that Siebold put together was his doing, just like “the rot that has continued ever since” at souths. Am I right?

You mean the team and pathways he inherited from Bennett .
The rot has followed Seibold, not the team or players.

Good to see plenty of Seibold fans are still out and about.

 

[Phobia]

Out in straight sets and rot has continued ever since.
Enjoy Maccas with Seibold

This has to be ragebait lmao.

South’s in 2018 made the prelim, and Seibold wasn’t there for the Spoon.

I have to say, you are absolutely top tier at baiting people into arguments lol.

 

[HoldenV8]

So if they had gone on to make the finals you would say seibold got them to the finals?

No, you wouldn't credit him with that.

Seibold was sacked when they were 15th. If they had improved to make the Finals after he was gone then it would be pretty obvious which coach there failed and which succeeded.

That Peter Gentle wasn't able to fix the mess that was left in the time he was given wasn't his fault.

 

[EOL now nesting on the GC]

How about this.

Anthony Seibold crafted Broncos. In his 2 years at the Helm the then Brisbane coach created a team that in the end was the worst performing Brisbane side in their history. He moved on almost all the old heads in the dressing room in a brutal clean out. He lost the dressing room, the old boys and the fans.... Regardless the fact Seibold did not coach the entire season given it was his roster and they were on 3 -15 when he left its safe to say hes 80% to blame. So while it is factual to say he didn't win the spoon perhaps we can all agree he should have at least been given a Spork( a spoon with a few slots cut out)

 

[eagle66]

You could argue that having decent cattle is in fact more of an indictment of the coaching, not less.

I don't disagree. However, I am one who believes in one in all in

 

[mickqld]

Hales , 4 failed seasons as a nsw cup coach, Titans failed, back at Manly failed. Move on.