Jake Simpkin signed until 2026

[susan]

Writing Da Silva off after one ordinary game with half the spine out is ridiculous. Outside a couple of communication mixups which is understandable given the halves he had, look at his passing from dummy half. It’s crisp and has a lot of width. Having him , Simkins and with Large in the wings would finally put us in with a chance at some quality in the 9 after being hampered by makeshift options for years.

Now for a tough edge backrower,quality prop and also take some bets on some mobile athletic youth in these positions for the future.

Fogarty will unleash our back talent .

That’s the way back

 

[LeonardCohen]

We aren’t buying Da Silva as the finished product; he’s played 22 first grade games. He is a rookie. We are interested because of his obvious ceiling. He didn’t need to outplay Simpkin to prove his worth tonight. He’s got a long career ahead of him and settling into first grade.

 

[Nordburg]

We aren’t buying Da Silva as the finished product; he’s played 22 first grade games. He is a rookie. We are interested because of his obvious ceiling. He didn’t need to outplay Simpkin to prove his worth tonight. He’s got a long career ahead of him and settling into first grade.

Agree,but does he get to that finished product with the current coaching at Manly?

 

[LeonardCohen]

Agree,but does he get to that finished product with the current coaching at Manly?

it’s still value added, either way. He’s a better prospect than what we currently have so if the same coach is responsible for the lesser talent, it should all balance out anyway 😂

 

[susan]

We aren’t buying Da Silva as the finished product; he’s played 22 first grade games. He is a rookie. We are interested because of his obvious ceiling. He didn’t need to outplay Simpkin to prove his worth tonight. He’s got a long career ahead of him and settling into first grade.

Outside of the errors I’d encourage people to take a closer look at the width and speed of his passing game tonight and compare it to Croker’s. It’s chalk and cheese.

I cannot understand Siebolds obsession with Croker especially with Simpkins showing obvious signs of improvement. Croker is slow , never runs, has an ordinary pass and although defending reasonably well, he also misses a lot. And he’s been doing that for 5 years. Hard to fathom …then again if you look at the style of forwards he has wanted maybe it’s not hard to fathom.

 

[LeonardCohen]

Outside of the errors I’d encourage people to take a closer look at the width and speed of his passing game tonight and compare it to Croker’s. It’s chalk and cheese.

I cannot understand Siebolds obsession with Croker especially with Simpkins showing obvious signs of improvement. Croker is slow , never runs, has an ordinary pass and although defending reasonably well, he also misses a lot. And he’s been doing that for 5 years. Hard to fathom …then again if you look at the style of forwards he has wanted maybe it’s not hard to fathom.

I know we tried to get Da Silva for 2024, but missed out. I think the coach knew Croker wasn’t going to be good enough but better options have to agree to sign with the club. Then Simpkin came along and looked good in patches but has struggled in defence at times; he’s willing but loses contact with big middle forwards quite a bit. So I think that’s where Croker comes into Seibs equation. He typically keeps the middle tighter, hence his immediately inclusion back from injury. However, he was poor and I heard he was going to be dropped, had it not been for injury this week.

So yeah, I think Seibs knows what we’ve currently got is not the answer…but previously, all we had and we were essentially stuck with.