Keppie told to leave, replaced by Tigers Alex Twal

[SeaEagleRock8]

Maybe this is what Seibs is looking for?

2nd best rackle effeciency for all props in the NRL this year.

Bench prop to come on, do his work and hold the middle.

With Tom, Koula, Garrick, Saab, Brooks, DCE, Olakau'atu, Schuster and Gordie we have plenty of attacking threat. Maybe he is looking for a workhorse defender

Who knows? Maybe he is also better at lateral movement and covering gaps which often seem to occur in our giant forward line. Better line speed?
One thing I do know is that I don't care which club he was at, if we sign him I have faith there will be some reason for it (!)

 

[XV-1]

Maybe this is what Seibs is looking for?

2nd best rackle effeciency for all props in the NRL this year.

Bench prop to come on, do his work and hold the middle.

With Tom, Koula, Garrick, Saab, Brooks, DCE, Olakau'atu, Schuster and Gordie we have plenty of attacking threat. Maybe he is looking for a workhorse defender

Something seriously wrong with those stats if Klemmer is on top.

 

[silvereagle]

Kaeloamotongi was the plan......and would have been a Super buy.....fact is, just maybe If we keep our "Star" players and continue to improve dummy half options and the addition of Luke Brooks, these "reliable, percentage" type players could be good enough ?

I think Alex Twal is a very smart buy. Not that long ago that Fatty Vautin was spruiking this guy as a potential SOO player. He will give us three major workhorses in our pack (with jake and croker) around which we can then blend in our power middles (Paeseka, Sips, Lodge, Alio Olio, Bullymore) and our danger points out wide (Haumole, Shuster, Ben). Throw in Gordon CKT and I think that might finally open up our new backline. Twal might also enable us to carry the Shu in the pack!!!

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Twal might also enable us to carry the Shu in the pack!!!

The clever rating was for this bit

 

[ManlyTragic]

I think Twal is low-frills dependable which has its advantages… Keppie is the girl-with-the-curl with regards to impact…

We cannot afford Kaeloamotongi (pretty sure I mucked that up) unless we get rid of Aloiai (who no one would take on any decent coin)…

At least the coaching staff are prepared to try something because our approach of the last few years is not working and blokes like Keppie have not improved… Paseka and Sips have a bit, but Keppie no…

Hey Frank… I have an adolescent daughter that is a ‘ girl with the curl’ and she has more attitude than Keppie!…. Unfortunately!!!

Just sayin’

 

[BOZO]

Nothing new on this thread
We have seen it all before

The Manly Moto is always
Leave your premiership winning mark or leave the club

No players Coach or Ceo is spared from accountability
To Live up to our legendary clubs High premiership winning standards

A Successful clubs greatest asset is the the Great people it Invests in

 

[Uber Eagle 72]

Not sure what to make of this. The upside I see is that the coach is going to have the team he wants and can be more fairly judged from this next year.

 

[Ben]

Look, I think Twal is a better player than Keppie but I'd like a bit more.....punch....attacking upside I guess

He averages 10m per hit up plus defends at almost 99% tackle efficiency and low error count Can’t really ask for more than that from a bargain priced prop. Should be a very astute signing.

 

[40 nil]

I checked to see if Twal is managed by Isaac Moses, but he is managed by Pacific Sports Management, Drummoyne (Gavin Orr) which has high profile clients from various clubs. Manly clients are Arthur, Sykes, Parker, Matterson & Lawton (Cade Cust is among the Super League clients).

NRL/Rugby League - Pacific Sports Management

www.pacificsportsmanagement.com

 

[Eagle 1]

Look, I think Twal is a better player than Keppie but I'd like a bit more.....punch....attacking upside I guess

He's an honest toiler at best, for Twal to be told to find another club from a side that just picked up it's 2nd wooden trophy in a row tells you all that you need to know.

 

[Coops manly]

Keppie is extremely lazy . His effort areas lack greatly constantly getting found out in the middle of the field in defence.
Also good for am error or two each game with the ball.
Manly have been very patient with him but he doesn't seem like he is improving unfortunately time to go!

 

[double hoops]

If it frees up cash for Keaon to come on board. We need a forward leader first and foremost. A work horse never goes astray. Twal more experienced than Condon.

 

[tookey]

I think Alex Twal is a very smart buy. Not that long ago that Fatty Vautin was spruiking this guy as a potential SOO player. He will give us three major workhorses in our pack (with jake and croker) around which we can then blend in our power middles (Paeseka, Sips, Lodge, Alio Olio, Bullymore) and our danger points out wide (Haumole, Shuster, Ben). Throw in Gordon CKT and I think that might finally open up our new backline. Twal might also enable us to carry the Shu in the pack!!!

Twal for SOO?

Vautin has had too many head knocks

 

[tookey]

If it frees up cash for Keaon to come on board. We need a forward leader first and foremost. A work horse never goes astray. Twal more experienced than Condon.

Keaon is a potential 2025 signing as he is still under contract to souths for 2023 and no way they will let him go early

 

[Will on the hill]

Obviously not a flashy game breaker type but is one of the best reliable workhorse forwards in the game. Definitely an upgrade on Keppie. If we actually got him for less money it would be a fantastic signing.

 

[mkultra]

Whilst this isn't setting the world on fire, I like the approach we've had to recruitment lately. There isn't a heap of stars on the market and we probably couldn't afford them if there was. We are going through our roster and comparing what we have to what's available. If what's available is an improvement we are making moves... it might be only incrementally but it's still an improvement. Seibold needs to have Manly going better next year and whilst we are signing big names, I feel we are usually replacing with a bit better.

The stats shown in this thread indicate that Twal > Keppie. I think it was Ryan who was comparing Aitasi James and Sam Fainu the other day. Same deal, not world beaters but an uptick on what we had last year. Yes, I agree there is likely more upside in Fainu but there is risk in waiting for that and paying overs too early.

Little steps like this help sure up the base while we wait for our young guns to develop or we a superstar becomes available.

We just need to make sure we don't overspend or give out longer than needed terms.

Seems like smart business to me.

Having said all that, I think I'm about done seeing Tiger's players heading our way. Twal can be the last.

Go Manly. Can't wait for '24!

 

[Frogz]

Twal is not signed sealed yet is he. I read many clubs were looking at him. For me No thanks. (My opinion only).

 

[MissKate]

This obsession with recruiting from the tigers is seriously doing my head in

 

[XV-1]

Seems to be everywhere now. Keppie will be snapped up quickly I would have thought.

Manly forward given permission to speak to rival clubs

Manly Sea Eagles forward Sean Keppie could be set to leave the club after he has been given permission to speak to rival clubs.

www.zerotackle.com

 

[master blaster]

Twal is not signed sealed yet is he. I read many clubs were looking at him. For me No thanks. (My opinion only).

same here, havent seen it to be official anywhere yet