Our best recruit from each NRL club

[Chip and Chase]

Getting bored with the coaching speculation threads so for a bit of fun name your best player we have recruited from each of the other NRL clubs (past and present). Must have played first grade before coming here, and can't be returning players who left Manly and came back.

Some obvious ones that probably aren't contentious

Parra - Killer
Norths - Cliffy
Penrith - Dessie
St George - Snoz

let's hear some others.

 

[Shoe1]

Getting bored with the coaching speculation threads so for a bit of fun name your best player we have recruited from each of the other NRL clubs (past and present). Must have played first grade before coming here, and can't be returning players who left Manly and came back.

Some obvious ones that probably aren't contentious

Parra - Killer
Norths - Cliffy
Penrith - Dessie
St George - Snoz

let's hear some others.

Timing is everything chip. This would be an awesome post if there was no other stuff happening :0)

 

[Chip and Chase]

Post in the coaching speculation thread then come here and make a nomination whilst thinking about your next post in the coaching speculation thread

Lucky door prize for someone who comes up with a South Queensland Crusher

 

[Frogz]

Storm - Matt Orford
Dragons - Brent Kite

 

[Chip and Chase]

Perth Reds - Craig Innes

 

[47MVEagle]

Cement
OJ

 

[lsz]

What about trying to pick a recruit from Souths or wests....geez they gave us some players

 

[Chip and Chase]

Cement
OJ

OJ debuted here. Not a recruit

Cement came from Wests. Maybe Boyd or Brown lay claim there ?

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Interesting, top of my head so might be missing some obvious ones

Raiders - Robertson
Wests Tigers - Taupau
Newcastle - Kennedy

 

[HappilyManly]

Cows - Farah
Broncs - Dunamis Lui
(Chez and Matty rejected)
Titans - BJ soon to be LG
Knights - BK
Norths - Cliffy
Souths - Big Ian, Tezza, Serdaris
Easts - Crusher, Bousted
Tigers - Steve Knight
Dogs - Gearin
Wests - Boyd
Parra - Killer, Wolfie
Penrith - Api
Sharks - Nathan Long
Saints - Kitey
Raiders - Robbo
Scumos - Ox
Warriors - Feleti Mateo

Nz - Ridgey
Uk - Reilly
Samoa - Matai
Tonga - Hoppa
Fiji - Api

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

Warriors - Hiku

 

[47MVEagle]

What about trying to pick a recruit from Souths or wests....geez they gave us some players

Robert's
Tezza

 

[47MVEagle]

OJ debuted here. Not a recruit

Cement came from Wests. Maybe Boyd or Brown lay claim there ?

OJ returned though.

 

[47MVEagle]

T-Rex
Cheyse Blair

 

[manlyfan76]

Castleford. Mal reiley

 

[Chip and Chase]

Warriors - Hiku

Debuted for us

 

[Chip and Chase]

OJ returned though.

Returning players don’t count

 

[47MVEagle]

Returning players don’t count

Okay

 

[Chip and Chase]

Cows - Farah
Broncs - Chez and Matty rejected
Titans - BJ soon to be LG
Knights - BK
Norths - Cliffy
Souths - Big Ian
Easts - Crusher
Tigers - Steve Knight
Dogs - Cement Gillespie
Wests - Boyd
Parra - Killer, Wolfie
Penrith - Api
Raiders - Kitey, Robbo
Scumos - Ox
Warriors - Hiku
Nz - Ridgey
Uk - Reilly
Samoa - Matai
Tonga - Hoppa
Fiji - Api

Chez and ballin debuted here
Cement came from Maggies
Kite from Dragons
Hiku debuted here

 

[Frogz]

Cows - Farah
Broncs - Chez and Matty rejected
Titans - BJ soon to be LG
Knights - BK
Norths - Cliffy
Souths - Big Ian, Tezza, Serdaris
Easts - Crusher, Bousted
Tigers - Steve Knight
Dogs - Cement Gillespie
Wests - Boyd
Parra - Killer, Wolfie
Penrith - Api
Raiders - Kitey, Robbo
Scumos - Ox
Warriors - Hiku
Nz - Ridgey
Uk - Reilly
Samoa - Matai
Tonga - Hoppa
Fiji - Api

KIte was Dragons, never played first grade for Raiders. Debut in First Grade for Dragons in 2002