This is a great topic and is EASIILLLLY sorted by creating a to go and to keep list as I will do below...
To Go ...
1. George Rose - After his NSW CUP performances is on the outer big time, unless a big adjustment is made to his fitness and attitude.
2. Brent Kite - No real reason, just getting on and blocking the path for player such as Stromquist and Cunningham.
3. Jason King - Same as above
4 Junior Palou - has had the same disease as Rose for years now and is taking up salary cap money. If I was a treelopper at the Sea Eagles I would of removed that pieces of dead wood ages ago.
5. Tim Wynn - Just a Barry. Little to no skill. Needs big improvement.
6. Liam Foran - In .. Complete, complete, complete. Riding on coat tails of his Bro.
7. Liam Roach - Speaking of coat tails, riding on his surname. Was seen at NSW Cup not with his team members but with beverages on the hill.
8. Ben Shorter - The "Luke Covell" of The Manly Sea Eagles. Should never even be mentioned in the same sentence as the words "First grade"
9. David Williams - Needs to take a large pay cut and to stay fit to get off this list.
10. Jason Annear -alittle bland, Fingers crossed for improvement. Similiar to player below.
11. Tim Burrell -Should be a future superstar for the size of him, but is like a combination of the Tinman and the Lion out of the Wizard of Oz... needs to go on a quest to find a heart and some courage (and along the way hopeful a fend as well.)
12 Brett Stewart - Is a criminal and I don't mean because his previous issues, but because he is thieving so much of our salary cap.
13 Darcy Lussick - Good young player but needs to prove himself as Mauro and Harrison have.
14 Joe Galuvao - Same as Kite and King.
15 David Penna -Couldn't coach a poo out of a bum as seen by last years Toyota Cup Result. Still need to work on his fitness running the water as well.
Now, the...
To Keep ...
1. The rest of the NRL team list.
2. Jorge Taufua - One big strong fast unit, maybe our version of Conrad Hurrell.
3. Magnus Stromquist - The complete package and in need of the current team selection committee wake from there slumber and give our future Paul Gallen more game time. If they are reading this WAKE UP!!!
4. Ben Falcone - Has shown sublime form at NSW Cup level in the first two rounds, quite the opposite to a couple of other players above him in regards to the number he wears on his back.
5. Liam Higgins - Similiar to the player below. Well rounded, solid, committed and deservse more opportunities.
6. Mitch Jowett - Read above.
7. Jamie Anderson - Has improved his defence and is a great attacker could slot into hooker back rower edge or other club if we are not careful
8. Josie Hawkins - Trains the house down and is a workhorse in all aspects, not to mention that he has a head like a beaten favourite. Our version of Dallas Johnson or David Stagg.
The Players in the "To go" list are halting the "To keep" lists' progress and also our salary cap. So I hope to God or in my case 2vs that the club WAKES UP.