What are peoples thoughts ?
In theory I suppose it's a good idea, but in practice I'm not sure if I'm a fan yet. I think it makes it harder on the umpires and if anything they are less likely to give decisions for fear of having egg on their faces if it gets overturned, especially once the fielding side use their 2 challenges.
It's definitely not a perfect system as seen by a couple of the decisions in the Eng v WI test.
In theory I suppose it's a good idea, but in practice I'm not sure if I'm a fan yet. I think it makes it harder on the umpires and if anything they are less likely to give decisions for fear of having egg on their faces if it gets overturned, especially once the fielding side use their 2 challenges.
It's definitely not a perfect system as seen by a couple of the decisions in the Eng v WI test.