Selection Headache

[Sheikheagle]

So who misses out when Darcy comes back. Would hate to see Hastings miss out as providing excellent impact.

 

[HappilyManly]

Mr Plod will have a well earned rest and Rep selections in 4 weeks may sort it out

 

[The Wheel]

I reckon Darcy needed a run or two when he came back / I think he should have a week or 2 with Blacktown before being considered.

My view is that the bench should have 2 props, second rower and a utility. They won't dropvAFB or Nate so it is either Brown or Hastings. If Jackson keeps slotting goals like Friday when he comes on I reckon it could've Brown who gets the 18th man role

 

[Kevinward777]

Has to be Brown, he's been much improved the last 2 weeks. But Hastings, Nate and AFB have all had serious impact coming off the bench. It's a no brainer. Hastings had 2 important touches leading up to a try, kicked a couple of goals (one from the sideline) and executed a beautiful kick into touch from dummy half against the Bunnies.

 

[Fluffy]

Depends on other injuries,some of which we probably are not aware of

 

[Kevinward777]

Mr Plod will have a well earned rest and Rep selections in 4 weeks may sort it out

Mate he has been excellent the last 4 games he's played. Nate's defence in the middle of the field has been exceptional, as has been his strong runs and physical presence. Just as DCE 40/20 was the catalyst for the win on Friday, so too was Nate's hit against Canberra when we were trailing by 2 try's and he knocked the ball loose with brutal contact. Give him a break man, he's doing exactly what Baz and Bozo signed him to do:

 

[Shoe1]

Also how do we fit James Roberts and will hoppa into the back line?

 

[HappilyManly]

Mate he has been excellent the last 4 games he's played. Nate's defence in the middle of the field has been exceptional, as has been his strong runs and physical presence. Just as DCE 40/20 was the catalyst for the win on Friday, so too was Nate's hit against Canberra when we were trailing by 2 try's and he knocked the ball loose with brutal contact. Give him a break man, he's doing exactly what Baz and Bozo signed him to do:

Exactly, he needs to be regularly refreshed as I noted - no critique was passed.
Therefore the selection of Darcy will not push anyone out

 

[Kevinward777]

Exactly, he needs to be regularly refreshed as I noted - no critique was passed.
Therefore the selection of Darcy will not push anyone out

Fair enough, the Mr Plod reference veiled your positivity.

 

[HappilyManly]

Fair enough, the Mr Plod reference veiled your positivity.

It's his nickname on ST or sometimes Mr Poo

I don't believe that having a glut of available players does anything but help a Coach. Each player vying to keep their spot, can only push them to excel

 

[Kevinward777]

It's his nickname on ST or sometimes Mr Poo

I don't believe that having a glut of available players does anything but help a Coach. Each player vying to keep their spot, can only push them to excel

I agree with you there, this season is such a contrast in that aspect compared to the ladies two.

 

[manlyfan76]

Brown needs a rest.

 

[HappilyManly]

The Sunday Footy Show had the Raiders Croker (?) on.
He commented on how Manly were so committed to each other.
'Every time there was an issue, they all ran in and helped out their player '

 

[stoodamire]

No one.

Unless injuries, suspension or rep selection.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

The Sunday Footy Show had the Raiders Croker (?) on.
He commented on how Manly were so committed to each other.
'Every time there was an issue, they all ran in and helped out their player '

This year might be a year too soon, but by next year this side will be premiership contenders - barring major injuries.

 

[Little Grubber Kick]

This year might be a year too soon, but by next year this side will be premiership contenders - barring major injuries.

Indeed, it will be a very sad day to lose this years GF (I just hope it's not another boat race) but as they say you have to lose one before you can win one......

 

[STSK]

Last two weeks Brown has come one for Siro and Frank, and it has worked.

The only way, with the current game plan we can drop Brown is if Marty shifts to an edge for a stint.