Who do you hate more? NAS or JWH

[ricardo]

They're both cheap shot merchants that play for untouchable teams ... but:

Who do you hate more? NAS or JWH?

 

[ricardo]

With apologies to @Kaufusi's Elbow for not including the cheapest of cheapshot merchants.

 

[CoreyWaddellSuperFan]

Tough one. Both grubs.
Funnily enough, sometime back I read an article about how JWH and his wife flip houses outside of footy. It was all very design based and, if I didn't know anything about how he played, I would have thought he was quite a lovely bloke!

 

[maxta]

JWH after Friday
To be honest, I was kind of jealous seeing him intimidating players, running over players and smashing players in a Roosters jersey when he was 1 of our own...
But over the past few seasons as he has lost lateral movement and the game has sped up, the big dominant contacts have been replaced by cheap shots....
That Elbow drop with full weight on young Fulton was not tough and in fact, was a downright dirty dog act that could easily have caused a serious injury....and the bloke gets a fine Uncle Nick can pay with the change on his bathroom floor.
I reckon JWH will seriously injure a player before long and it will not be from nthe brutal man he once was, but a similar grub act like Friday night.

 

[rj90]

JWH always

 

[Will on the hill]

No hate here, moderate dislike for both but that would miraculously disappear if they played for Manly.

 

[north coast eagle]

Both are oversized grub/ psychopaths who tend to pick on the smallest players on the field. JWH is more blatant but NAS likes beating up people off the field as well. Too hard to seperate. Despite their size, one day they will pick on the wrong person and pay the consequences.

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

JWH for sure , but both are GRUBS

 

[Shoe1]

They are psychos and completely unpleasant on the field, but I enjoy watching them and admire their extreme behaviour (on field). So I don’t hate either of them.

 

[bob dylan]

I also hate seeing JWH in Roosters jersey.

He should be one of ours. He is tough and dirty and nasty and all the things that are needed to win a competition.

the other bloke is a nuff. Don't even rate him has a footballer or a thug . He should go to the Titans with Kevin The Kat and Tino the Timid.

 

[Rocky]

Always amazed when the biggest dude on the field resorts to cheap shots. Says a lot.

As others have mentioned JWH is even grubbier these days given he is ageing.

NAS is just a loose cannon on and off the field. He's capable of anything.

 

[Chip and Chase]

With JWH is almost pathological. Not sure if that is nature or nurture, but he has an issue.

If we are having discussions about biggest grubs in the NRL then Cody Walker has to be in the mix.

 

[ALinda]

Both the dirtiest of grubs and as bad as each other. Imo we have a tie.

 

[Sheikheagle]

Nelson not charged WTF.

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

NAS? I enjoyed my time at the Naval Air Station in the early 1980s - until the Falklands War, politics and the Royal Strayan Arse Farce (Albo’s Penguins - one in a million can fly) f-cked everything up. Nowra is one of my favourite regional centres.

So it would have to be JWH.

 

[Heckenberg]

I respect JWH level of psycho.. I would probably love him if he was still at manly. So yeah i hate JWH more. Nelson is a **** but he's less animated

 

[Son of Manly Beach]

They're both cheap shot merchants that play for untouchable teams ... but:

Who do you hate more? NAS or JWH?

Such a hard call
So much so that I can’t even vote
I just can’t decide who’s the bigger grub!

 

[ManEagle]

Haven't we had enough hate ?

In saying that JWH tends to single out the rookie or lesser size players for his grub antics so he gets the nod but only by a short elbow.

 

[HoldenV8]

Am I the only one who didn't actually think there was much in what JWH did?? Sorry but any veteran forward, especially a front rower, worth their weight would do that to any rookie as a welcome to first grade.

A mountain out of a mole hill IMO.

 

[Son of Manly Beach]

Am I the only one who didn't actually think there was much in what JWH did?? Sorry but any veteran forward, especially a front rower, worth their weight would do that to any rookie as a welcome to first grade.

A mountain out of a mole hill IMO.

Look I agree, I’d be happy with him if I was a Roosters fan I suppose. Because he does show some ticker. Still a grub though 😂