Josh Addo-Carr

[Mango]

Now that Tim Simona has signed another year extension, all five ( Simona, Rankin, Naiqama ,Nofoaluma and tedesco)
Are on contract till the end of "07"
Addo-Carr is only signed for this year.
Also the other two man children are up this year.... So tigers salary would be running tight.
Maybe a good Centre prospect?

 

[double hoops]

He's quick. Thats always handy.

 

[Turbo]

Nah he is a winger, plus putting walker at 5/8 next year IMO is righting off any chance we have of finals. He is really hurting us ATM, he is playing well individually but we just can't have him at 5/8 and expect a fluent backline. Imagine if walker used snake and kapow properly! We would be a bigger threat down that edge. We can solve all the backline problems with signing a 5/8 hopefully it's Norman but wouldn't mind green either.

 

[pjayz]

If we go after an up and coming back, then I'd go for Javid Bowen from the Cowboys (another poster mentioned him and I think he would be a great choice). They have re-signed their backline and he is more than ready for first grade.

 

[Shoe1]

"Josh Addo-Carr" the name sounds like an amalgam of about 20 gen y players.

 

[KOMORI]

Without having any clue whatsoever about this bloke's footy talent, it's a firm no from me.

Cherry-Evans, Fonoau-Blake....

That's enough hyphenated surnames for me thank you

 

[Shoe1]

"Javid Bowen" that sounds like a gen y player to me.

 

[Mango]

Well a winger then

Nah he is a winger, plus putting walker at 5/8 next year IMO is righting off any chance we have of finals. He is really hurting us ATM, he is playing well individually but we just can't have him at 5/8 and expect a fluent backline. Imagine if walker used snake and kapow properly! We would be a bigger threat down that edge. We can solve all the backline problems with signing a 5/8 hopefully it's Norman but wouldn't mind green either.

Not

If we go after an up and coming back, then I'd go for Javid Bowen from the Cowboys (another poster mentioned him and I think he would be a great choice). They have re-signed their backline and he is more than ready for first grade.

So the choice of newbies is -

Addo- Carr
Javid Bowen
Kerrod Holland

I would go kerrod ( if that is a real name?) in a heart beat..
The kid has a real presence...
But Bozo might have to work a bit harder to break his "17" contract.

 

[Turbo]

Well a winger then

Not

So the choice of newbies is -

Addo- Carr
Javid Bowen
Kerrod Holland

I would go kerrod ( if that is a real name?) in a heart beat..
The kid has a real presence...
But Bozo might have to work a bit harder to break his "17" contract.

ATM for 2017 we don't need a centre, we need a 5/8. As for 2018 we are going to need to replace Skivvi, and holland would be the go.

 

[double hoops]

If we go after an up and coming back, then I'd go for Javid Bowen from the Cowboys (another poster mentioned him and I think he would be a great choice). They have re-signed their backline and he is more than ready for first grade.

I'm not sure he would move down south. But Bowen would be my first choice as well.

 

[madmax]

Why chase other so called 'prospects' when we have our own great 5/8 prospect in in Nicho Hynes????????????? I think DCE & Nicho would be brilliant together! He's already trained with the 1st grade squad pre-season & had a wonderful NYC campaign last year & is playing well in a beaten team this year. We gambled on both DCE & Foran when they were Nicho's age & look at what they've achieved, so why not give the kid a chance. I think maybe we need a good solid 2nd rower to compliment Taupau & Buhrer instead, personally................??

 

[Turbo]

Fox sports say addo Carr is going to sign with Melbourne on 3 year deal

 

[Fluffy]

Now that Tim Simona has signed another year extension, all five ( Simona, Rankin, Naiqama ,Nofoaluma and tedesco)
Are on contract till the end of "07"
Addo-Carr is only signed for this year.
Also the other two man children are up this year.... So tigers salary would be running tight.
Maybe a good Centre prospect?

and i thought DCE's contract was long but a 91 year contract seems outrageously optimistic

 

[Turbo]

Why chase other so called 'prospects' when we have our own great 5/8 prospect in in Nicho Hynes????????????? I think DCE & Nicho would be brilliant together! He's already trained with the 1st grade squad pre-season & had a wonderful NYC campaign last year & is playing well in a beaten team this year. We gambled on both DCE & Foran when they were Nicho's age & look at what they've achieved, so why not give the kid a chance. I think maybe we need a good solid 2nd rower to compliment Taupau & Buhrer instead, personally................??

no it's too big a risk to go into another season with an unknown 5/8. He may be a good player but he is a 20 year. DCE already has enough pressure teaching walker, we need an established half

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Might be time to start writing that Ph.D on the growing prevalence of double-barrelled surnames in rugby league.

 

[nightster]

Why chase other so called 'prospects' when we have our own great 5/8 prospect in in Nicho Hynes????????????? I think DCE & Nicho would be brilliant together! He's already trained with the 1st grade squad pre-season & had a wonderful NYC campaign last year & is playing well in a beaten team this year. We gambled on both DCE & Foran when they were Nicho's age & look at what they've achieved, so why not give the kid a chance. I think maybe we need a good solid 2nd rower to compliment Taupau & Buhrer instead, personally................??

& Tom Wright

 

[nightster]

no it's too big a risk to go into another season with an unknown 5/8. He may be a good player but he is a 20 year. DCE already has enough pressure teaching walker, we need an established half

unknown?

 

[madmax]

no it's too big a risk to go into another season with an unknown 5/8. He may be a good player but he is a 20 year. DCE already has enough pressure teaching walker, we need an established half

DCE & Foran were 20 yr olds & 'unknowns'!!! Most of the other 5/8 players mentioned are unknowns also!! Who taught DCE & Foran?

 

[TagMonster]

As much as Norman would he a good buy, he will cost upwards of 700k. Not worth that much. Nico is playing well and should he given first crack.

 

[lsz]

A big yes for me (I just want to see him in the same team Addin)