Pre-Game Manly V Broncos [Round 13, 2025]

Kick Off In:
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds

V

0 0
4 Pines Park

31 May 2025 07:35 PM


Team Lists


What did our coach do with that $4'million?

He bought Woods, Brown, Tevaga, TKO, Lodge, Chee Kam, and he extended Toff Sipley.

Terrible recruitment from a guy who doesn't seem capable of getting the balance right. At the Broncos he released too much experience while at Manly he's gone way over the top in adding "experience." If he can get us into the finals this year, I'd be blown away and prepared to back him to make a few signings to freshen up the squad. If he doesn't lead us to finals, he should be replaced by another coach who can be entrusted to rebuild the roster in coming weeks.
Yes feathered friend , This is his bed and now he has to lie on it
No Excuses !
 
What did our coach do with that $4'million?

He bought Woods, Brown, Tevaga, TKO, Lodge, Chee Kam, and he extended Toff Sipley.

Terrible recruitment from a guy who doesn't seem capable of getting the balance right. At the Broncos he released too much experience while at Manly he's gone way over the top in adding "experience." If he can get us into the finals this year, I'd be blown away and prepared to back him to make a few signings to freshen up the squad. If he doesn't lead us to finals, he should be replaced by another coach who can be entrusted to rebuild the roster in coming weeks.
Find this very hard to believe, have you got a breakdown on what these players are on or were on ?
 
No, but we had enough money to offer Flegler 675k a season before Seibold arrived. What happened to that money? Obviously it was spent on the squad. Who did we sign in 23-25?
I dont know, but just as well we didn't get Flegler as he hasn't played at all for 18months or so and may never play again ,imagine the outrage on here if we had signed another high priced player only to find him on the side lines for the next few years ,we wouldnt be running the likes of Lodge and Sipley we would be cap in hand trying to get Nate Myles back
 
I dont know, but just as well we didn't get Flegler as he hasn't played at all for 18months or so and may never play again ,imagine the outrage on here if we had signed another high priced player only to find him on the side lines for the next few years ,we wouldnt be running the likes of Lodge and Sipley we would be cap in hand trying to get Nate Myles back
We got lucky with Flegler for sure.
 
The Seibold Scavengers are out in full force.

$4m has now gone missing. Time for toovey to demand an investigation.
Not at all. It's just posters like yourself keep going on about us not having enough money to sign a decent forward or two. Apparently we could only afford stop gap older guys according to you. No one is accusing Seibold of anything other than spending the cap very poorly. You're just deflecting because you have had your pants pulled down.

675k for Flegler could have bought us a couple of YOUNGER MOBILE FORWARDS.

MAYBE EVEN A BACKROWER.
 
675k for Flegler could have bought us a couple of YOUNGER MOBILE FORWARDS.

MAYBE EVEN A BACKROWER
Which YOUNGER MOBILE FORWARDS wanted to leave wherever they were, and come to Manly?

It sometimes amuses me when people talk as though any player will happily go anywhere they are offered. Never that simple.

Clearly you need a) someone who can play footy plus b) someone whose personality will fit with the squad plus c) someone whose character will enhance the club not embarrass it plus d) someone who actually wants to move and play with this club.

If recruiting was as easy as some suggest then every club would be in the top 4 every year!
 
MATCH OFFICIALS:

Adam "Six More against Manly " Gee
Referee

Dave Munro
Touch Judge

Michael Wise
Touch Judge

TBA
Standby Referee

TBA
Standby Touch Judge

Chris "You're on report & you're on report & you're on report & you're on report " Butler
Bunker Review Official


-------------------------------------------------------------------------

We are screwed.

The only way that it could have been worse was to have Peter "Daly! He's got 10 in the bin & he's got 10 in the bin & he's got 10 in the bin " Gough involved in some way too as maybe a Touchie.
 
Not at all. It's just posters like yourself keep going on about us not having enough money to sign a decent forward or two. Apparently we could only afford stop gap older guys according to you. No one is accusing Seibold of anything other than spending the cap very poorly. You're just deflecting because you have had your pants pulled down.

675k for Flegler could have bought us a couple of YOUNGER MOBILE FORWARDS.

MAYBE EVEN A BACKROWER.
Are you privy to the clubs recruitment process & who has final say? I’d suggest you have no idea mate. Siebold DOES not have final say on recruitment. There are a number of officials who make these decisions. To say Siebold bought this player or that player & wasted our salary cap on players with a use by date is total BS! Im not sticking up for him but it’s getting a little monotonous with the Siebold blaming & player bagging.
 
Are you privy to the clubs recruitment process & who has final say? I’d suggest you have no idea mate. Siebold DOES not have final say on recruitment. There are a number of officials who make these decisions. To say Siebold bought this player or that player & wasted our salary cap on players with a use by date is total BS! Im not sticking up for him but it’s getting a little monotonous with the Siebold blaming & player bagging.
Fair enough Max.
 
$CE
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0929.webp
    IMG_0929.webp
    43.8 KB · Views: 16

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

2020 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 11 9 0 2 74 20
2 Raiders 12 9 0 3 70 18
3 Warriors 11 8 0 3 -1 18
4 Storm 10 6 0 4 135 16
5 Sharks 12 7 0 5 44 14
6 Rabbitohs 11 6 0 5 -52 14
7 Cowboys 10 4 1 5 -32 13
8 Broncos 11 5 0 6 42 12
9 Sea Eagles 11 5 0 6 18 12
10 Dragons 10 4 0 6 -11 12
11 Roosters 11 5 0 6 -20 12
12 Tigers 11 5 0 6 -54 12
13 Dolphins 12 5 0 7 42 10
14 Knights 11 4 0 7 -55 10
15 Eels 11 4 0 7 -79 10
16 Titans 10 3 0 7 -100 10
17 Panthers 11 3 1 7 -21 9
Back
Top Bottom