NSW Cup 2025

[Brookie1973]

Yep, I'm no Lodge fanboy but he gotta come in.

The term “fanboy” has bad connotations on here. FYI.

 

[Brookie1973]

Lodge

66 mins
stint 1 48:53 minutes stint 2 17:14
22 runs 275 meters 107 post contact
5 tackle breaks
3.43 play the ball speed (best forward)
1 offload
29 tackles 1 miss

Good stats. Looks to be bashing the door down to get back in.

 

[The Insomniac]

A post game investigation discovered chewy on his boot.

Classic Stuey !

 

[Jay Eagle]

To be fair re lodge

How many players do the dogs have out at the moment? If the NRL is accurate (if) Casualty Ward

Almost all forwards. So he had a dominant display against an under strength line up

I am not saying he is not a decent player but talk of him being the best prop in the NRL? That is a million miles from the mark

I'm just saying..on his day when he actually "wants it" he's a beast.

Old school hard nosed prop with an offload and power..

You just wonder what's between the ears though.

 

[lsz]

I'm just saying..on his day when he actually "wants it" he's a beast.

Old school hard nosed prop with an offload and power..

You just wonder what's between the ears though.

Not much judging by previous actions....also not a great track record in recent years for injury

 

[manlyfan76]

Looks like they came home with a wet sail.

Sloop had a wide berth?

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Sloop had a wide berth?

The Aaron Schoupp sloop?

Or sloop John Bucknall, aka sloop John B.?

 

[manlyfan76]

The Aaron Schoupp sloop?

Or sloop John Bucknall, aka sloop John B.?

None from oar

 

[Phobia]

Walsh, Talau, Navale, all named in NSW Cup. Schoupp still in second row. Looks like the 14 jersey in first grade is either between a hooker or a back this year.

 

[deanm]

We got beaten 38-26 today in NSW Cup. Walsh was 7 , Tommy Talau played as did Navale

 

[The Who]

We got beaten 38-26 today in NSW Cup. Walsh was 7 , Tommy Talau played as did Navale

The news just keeps getting better . . . not!

 

[Ohgeez]

Zaidas Muagututia played 60 minutes for 77 run metres, 1 line break, 1 line break assist, 1 try assist, 31 tackles with 83.78% tackle efficiency & 1 error.

Walsh had 59 run metres, 2 line break assists, 2 try assists, 15 tackles 83.3% tackle efficiency & 1 error.

Navale backed up for 80 minutes with 125 run metres, 1 line break, 38 tackles with 80.5% tackle efficiency

Seems like there were some problems defensively for all of them but manly did also have a player in the bin which could explain some of it. According to NSW cup stats Navale overall is 97.4% Walsh is 87.5% & Zaidas is 92.2% in tackling efficiency for the season.

The Knock-On Effect NSW Cup Highlights | Round 12 - Eels v Sea Eagles

Relive the Round 12 highlights from Parramatta Eels v Manly Warringah Sea Eagles at Kellyville Park.

www.nswrl.com.au

 

[Ohgeez]

Check out the attempted chase down from Hugo Hart on the intercept try Parra scored, looks like a perfect athletic build for a modern day back rower. Didn’t catch him but good to see the effort from another young player who was playing SG Ball to start the season. Club must have some big wraps on him too

 

[KaZa]

Walsh looks more of a half back than Arthur. We should try Arthur at lock in nsw cup

 

[LeonardCohen]

Zaidas Muagututia played 60 minutes for 77 run metres, 1 line break, 1 line break assist, 1 try assist, 31 tackles with 83.78% tackle efficiency & 1 error.

Walsh had 59 run metres, 2 line break assists, 2 try assists, 15 tackles 83.3% tackle efficiency & 1 error.

Navale backed up for 80 minutes with 125 run metres, 1 line break, 38 tackles with 80.5% tackle efficiency

Seems like there were some problems defensively for all of them but manly did also have a player in the bin which could explain some of it. According to NSW cup stats Navale overall is 97.4% Walsh is 87.5% & Zaidas is 92.2% in tackling efficiency for the season.

The Knock-On Effect NSW Cup Highlights | Round 12 - Eels v Sea Eagles

Relive the Round 12 highlights from Parramatta Eels v Manly Warringah Sea Eagles at Kellyville Park.

www.nswrl.com.au

Really promising tackle efficiency from all involved 😂

 

[Ohgeez]

Really promising tackle efficiency from all involved 😂

Haha yep, since Navale & Zaidas efficiency for the year is both over 90% I’m going to just hope they were scrambling & missed a few of their tackles when we had a player in the bin 😂

 

[aidan]

Definitely have to cut Navale some slack there considering he played 15 minutes in first grade and backed it up with 80 minutes at lock in reserve grade less than a day later. Normally he barely misses a tackle. And Zaidas is coming along really nicely by the looks of it. Improving his stats in reserve grade every week. Playing bigger minutes now too. Will be interesting to see what happens when Gordie returns.

 

[Smokin Joe]

Hart starting in second row today,very big rise from starting year in Ball,but was on a T&T in offseason.

 

[double hoops]

Hart starting in second row today,very big rise from starting year in Ball,but was on a T&T in offseason.

He's pretty quick. The type of player I'd love to see in our top team. What you reckon? Still 12 -18 mths away. Or an outside chance to debut later this year?

 

[Smokin Joe]

He's pretty quick. The type of player I'd love to see in our top team. What you reckon? Still 12 -18 mths away. Or an outside chance to debut later this year?

How long is a piece of string?
His rise has been meteoric and probably unpredicted,but his cameo in the trial at the start of the year was impressive.
I sort of think Seibold will stick with experience this year and doubt we will be high enough up the ladder to have the luxury of just giving a kid a few minutes(for me I would do it anyway).
Looks a good shot of an NRL contract or at least a supplementary contract for next year.
The club obviously rated him and were prepared to pay him to get him on a T&T contract.
I just think he could be something special in time.