Oldfield v Whare

[simon64]

After tonight I'm more convinced than ever that Oldfield should stay at Whare's expense.

Whare's a more than decent centre but he's no winger.

 

[dowdz]

Oldfield

Thought he was good tonight. Not sure about others but probably a better wing option instead of whare.

 

[TonganEagle]

100% agree, think he's a fantastic center but hasn't got the finishing abilities like jorge or olfield

 

[Central Coast Eagle]

RE: Oldfield

Yeah he was awesome tonight!

 

[dowdz]

RE: Oldfield

Didn't see previous thread. Sorry please delete thanks mods

 

[Central Coast Eagle]

I have to agree with you!!

 

[Utility Player]

RE: Oldfield

Toss of the coin for mine, if he had passed early to DCE and stayed back for the Killer pass late in the 2nd half we could have had 2 more trys.

 

[Cochrane]

neither here nor there, i though Whare went alright tonight

 

[HK_Eagle]

Yes, Oldie looks a lot more comfortable in the wing position... however, he did make a couple of poor judgements this evening which were both potentially scoring opportunities...

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

RE: Oldfield

He's always good for a couple of tries when he gets a run.
Always liked him and wish he'd developed into a starting winger but he got overtaken by Juggernaut Jorge. Sorry to see him go to the Roosters (sorry for anybody who ends up there).

 

[north coast eagle]

Oldfield could of got us another two tries tonight by just implementing the basics. First example draw and pass and Cherry Evans scores under the posts. Second example if he stays behind his centre while the ball is still alive then he would of had a great opportunity in 2nd half to score with his pace. His talent is wasted by his poor concentration. I believe Toovey has it right.

 

[Kiwi Eagle]

RE: Oldfield

Halfway through the game I woulda gone him over Whare but he was caught positionally on attack a few times. That is where we really miss Wolf

 

[The Eagle Has Landed]

Oldfield could of got us another two tries tonight by just implementing the basics. First example draw and pass and Cherry Evans scores under the posts. Second example if he stays behind his centre while the ball is still alive then he would of had a great opportunity in 2nd half to score with his pace. His talent is wasted by his poor concentration. I believe Toovey has it right.

THIS

 

[Jatz Crackers]

If the result was against us Oldfiled would now be copping it here for some poor decisions and Whare for lack of involvement.

 

[Supesy]

Whare did an excellent job on Tate tonight, he couldnt do anything.

Whares defense was superb.

---

In saying that thought, I think Oldfields speed is second to none and thats all Lyon needs because he opens up the hole.

I also think Oldfield reads Lyons play a lot better, he seemed to be in the right place at the right time for every play.

Some huge calls coming up for Toovey....

Mauro is also being wasted on the bench, may as well of had Rose come on and give a good 25 mins of impact.

 

[MWSE]

All in all, a good problem for 2V to have to decide on.

 

[Lord Eagleton]

After tonight I'm more convinced than ever that Oldfield should stay at Whare's expense.

Whare's a more than decent centre but he's no winger.

Agreed man

 

[Canteen Worker]

Whare was huge tonight - great centre and big loss for us. Oldfield is a genuine centre and his pace was awesome. Pity about the inside ball to Daly!! That should have been a simple try.

 

[Terry-Randal]

we have lost two young future backs . I thought we could have kept one of them.

 

[BOZO]

we have lost two young future backs . I thought we could have kept one of them.

We made the right choice in Jorge Taufua. We cant keep them all Terry.