Post-Game Discussion Sharks v Manly [Round 21, 2023]

[Thewestisbest]

Maybe I’ve grown up and moved past the amateur argument of blaming the refs.

It's all good mate, I wasn't having a go at you. I enjoy reading your Devil's advocate perspective.

 

[Eagle 1]

Funny how you can pick the flogs that come on here pretending to be Manly supporters
They dissapear straight after a win

Flogs

Yeah, the perennial death riders come out on match days, they know who they are.

 

[HoldenV8]

At least he was consistent. He gave us all the calls in the first half.

I honestly don't know what Grant Atkins was thinking in the bunker confirming that try with a clear cut knock-on.

And that is why I think only Graham Annesley should be in the bunker throughout the round. Its not physically possible to have the same ref at each game, but it is possible with the bunker.

 

[XV-1]

How does a video ref review it in order to mandate an HIA, but not to advise the hit was high, penalty should be issued ?

Easy. It was the doctor in the bunker that said Jake had to come off.
Different person to the video ref.

 

[XV-1]

I honestly don't know what Grant Atkins was thinking in the bunker confirming that try with a clear cut knock-on.

And that is why I think only Graham Annesley should be in the bunker throughout the round. Its not physically possible to have the same ref at each game, but it is possible with the bunker.

What try was that?

I remember they scored on the next play when Woods tacked a guy and the ball was dropped by Cronulla - play on??

What about the first half when Hynes tripped Koula - play on??

 

[XV-1]

The other thing sharks are gone for 2023 which is a good thing.

Boy they are really in a bad way

How do u work that out.

Sharks are 6th and 3 points ahead of us.

 

[Eagle 1]

What’s the mail on Paseka ? How long is he out . Bully and Toff back in the team next week

They said a ligament strain 2 to 3 weeks. According to the 9 sideline reporter.

 

[2830 Eagle]

So happy we won the Steve Rogers trophy lol

 

[lsz]

Re the trip

Did anyone actually see it live? Was a call by the video ref after the play had rolled on

No chance of it being a penalty as the game had moved on

 

[Eagle 1]

What try was that?

I remember they scored on the next play when Woods tacked a guy and the ball was dropped by Cronulla - play on??

What about the first half when Hynes tripped Koula - play on??

Or the high shot on Jake, that missed by bunker boys, should of been a penalty right there and a momentum swing to us.

 

[davohan123]

How do u work that out.

Sharks are 6th and 3 points ahead of us.

They don't be doing any damage in September they will probably play finals footy but won't do much damage

 

[Will on the hill]

Re the trip

Did anyone actually see it live? Was a call by the video ref after the play had rolled on

No chance of it being a penalty as the game had moved on

Saw it live, was screaming into the abyss. Half a dozen of our players saw it too and were appealing to the ref.

 

[Sheikheagle]

Or the high shot on Jake, that missed by bunker boys, should of been a penalty right there and a momentum swing to us.

Apparently the video ref can only get involved in that instance only if it was a reportable offence. It’s a joke. Jake never stays down.

 

[Thewestisbest]

I don’t understand our side on occasion games we have a big lead & lose our way in defence focus ffs.

There were some serious aggravating circumstances that contributed to our defence falling away late. We need to aim to be better, but that was a gutsy win in the end.

 

[mickqld]

Jake hit in the head from a swinging arm. Off to HIA from the independent doctor but crickets from the fuking bunker. What a farce that was.

 

[Eagle 1]

So many dodgy ref decisions....we won but it doesn't feel like it.

Feels like the Storm game at Brookie a while back. They played Eagle Rock but nobody danced tho.

 

[StuBoot]

Soo...if you were told before hand that we'd win 30-26, we'd all take it, yes?
Then told we'd lose Paseka after 5 mins, Alioai in the 2nd half and Jake got a HIA leaving only one on the bench, we'd take it again and say how resilient we were, yes?

It's the score at the end that counts, the journey may be bumpy but we got there first and really that's all that counts.

 

[mickqld]

Apparently the video ref can only get involved in that instance only if it was a reportable offence. It’s a joke. Jake never stays down.

He did stay down to get assessed. It was a blatant fuking blind eye from the fukwit bunker clown.

 

[cc eagle]

Jake hit in the head from a swinging arm. Off to HIA from the independent doctor but crickets from the fuking bunker. What a farce that was.

Worst bunker decision ever, seen a lot less than that penalised

 

[HoldenV8]

What try was that?

I remember they scored on the next play when Woods tacked a guy and the ball was dropped by Cronulla - play on??

What about the first half when Hynes tripped Koula - play on??

The Ramien try after the Woods tackle.

St. Nicho penalised?? lol