That Reynolds 'try'

[c eagle]

pretty simple really......in every replay shown, the ref is standing over the play, watch as many replays as you like..... the ref standing over play, sending try upstairs= video ref has to give the green light.

 

[ManlyArmy]

If he put the ball down any shorter, he would've been in Queensland!

 

[globaleagle]

So now the big 'hoo ha' with having a player in the vid box is negated by the VID REFS being TO SCARED to OVER-RULE anything the ref's say.


That try was a total crock of ****e.

 

[DUFFMAN]

No Try

But when Baba was ruled to be caught in goal, Manly scored after that.
Baba made it back in to the field of play, so we got lucky there.
We had a few bad calls go against us but we played crap for the opening 60 minutes.
We will miss the 8 if we don't start playing like the first part of the season. Stupid penalties are costing us big time.

 

[Brissie Kid]

Go back to the Souths game at Brookie when Manly were mounting a comeback. Wolfman & Symonds both got "tries" where the on field referee said "try" but despite inconclusive replays the video referee went against the onfield referee & ruled no try.

 

[castle eagle]

No Try

But when Baba was ruled to be caught in goal, Manly scored after that.
Baba made it back in to the field of play, so we got lucky there.
We had a few bad calls go against us but we played crap for the opening 60 minutes.
We will miss the 8 if we don't start playing like the first part of the season. Stupid penalties are costing us big time.

the ref called held before barba hit the ground, hence the drop out

 

[Dan]

No Try

But when Baba was ruled to be caught in goal, Manly scored after that.
Baba made it back in to the field of play, so we got lucky there.
We had a few bad calls go against us but we played crap for the opening 60 minutes.
We will miss the 8 if we don't start playing like the first part of the season. Stupid penalties are costing us big time.

the ref called held before barba hit the ground, hence the drop out

Plus he put the ball down on the line when tackled in goal...that means he grounded it in goals 100% correct call