[Resurrected] Brandon Smith

[Nordburg]

Think you could be right, the chooks are trying to shift Smith and Young immediately, Crawley is saying the chooks want Daly as early as next week, could this this be true?

They don’t want him for this year.They want to announce him as early as next week.The Roosters are clearing the decks to upgrade other players and to seal the DCE deal,which was done long ago.Also a chance of a Joey Manu return

 

[Rafferty]

They don’t want him for this year.They want to announce him as early as next week.The Roosters are clearing the decks to upgrade other players and to seal the DCE deal,which was done long ago.Also a chance of a Joey Manu return

Cheers, pretty much just got home from work and had a quick read around, before seeing I was a little late to the party, after reading Daly’s thread, he looks like a wanker in that strip anyway……

 

[Ned]

 

[Peter C]

From memory I can't recall any Manly players who went to the Roosters and succeeded, apart from Johhny Mayes who actually went back to them, let's hope DCE follows in the same tradition as all the others.
Bob Fulton - fail
John Harvey - fail
Mike Eden - fail
Stuart Davis - fail
Gartner - fail
Vautin - fail
Doorey - fail
Elsegood - so so
O'Donnel - fail
Shearer - fail
Mal Kaufusi - fail
Oldfield - fail

 

[Vyssini]

From memory I can't recall any Manly players who went to the Roosters and succeeded, apart from Johhny Mayes who actually went back to them, let's hope DCE follows in the same tradition as all the others.
Bob Fulton - fail
John Harvey - fail
Mike Eden - fail
Stuart Davis - fail
Gartner - fail
Vautin - fail
Doorey - fail
Elsegood - so so
O'Donnel - fail
Shearer - fail
Mal Kaufusi - fail
Oldfield - fail

JWH?

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

JWH?

We don't mention him, lol

 

[Ron E. Gibbs]

From memory I can't recall any Manly players who went to the Roosters and succeeded, apart from Johhny Mayes who actually went back to them, let's hope DCE follows in the same tradition as all the others.
Bob Fulton - fail
John Harvey - fail
Mike Eden - fail
Stuart Davis - fail
Gartner - fail
Vautin - fail
Doorey - fail
Elsegood - so so
O'Donnel - fail
Shearer - fail
Mal Kaufusi - fail
Oldfield - fail

Luke Phillips? Ivan Cleary (by way of the Bears)?

 

[Peter C]

JWH?

Yeah, forgot about that one, but we don't mention him

 

[Jimmie]

Cheers, pretty much just got home from work and had a quick read around, before seeing I was a little late to the party, after reading Daly’s thread, he looks like a wanker in that strip anyway……

View attachment 30156

steggles suits him

 

[Stuey Davis’s Socks]

From memory I can't recall any Manly players who went to the Roosters and succeeded, apart from Johhny Mayes who actually went back to them, let's hope DCE follows in the same tradition as all the others.
Bob Fulton - fail
John Harvey - fail
Mike Eden - fail
Stuart Davis - fail
Gartner - fail
Vautin - fail
Doorey - fail
Elsegood - so so
O'Donnel - fail
Shearer - fail
Mal Kaufusi - fail
Oldfield - fail

Agree with all of that except I’d push Bazza Elsegood up to a pass. My admittedly hazy memory tells me he went well at the chooks. Checked his stats and they tend to agree, at least in terms of try scoring where he had a much better strike rate at the chooks:

Manly - 25 tries from 72 games over 4 years (93 - 96)

Easts - 35 tries from 77 games over 4 years (97 - 90).

 

[The '47ers]

Cheers, pretty much just got home from work and had a quick read around, before seeing I was a little late to the party, after reading Daly’s thread, he looks like a wanker in that strip anyway……

View attachment 30156

That pic made me vomit in my mouth a little