is it a mistake to keep Lewis?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Like what alot of other posters have said.

Too similar to Buhrer and Leary. Don't see the need for Sharkie and don't rate him that highly either.

However, seeing as he'll be wearing the Manly colours next year, i'll give him a few rounds to prove himself.
 
I can only see him being signed by Bozo because of the new interchange rules. The only real problem then is we will lack a true "size"/ "power" 2nd rower.

Backrow will probably be Buhrer/Leary/Brown.
 
He is an outstanding player with a huge ticker. He is also one of the best utility players in the game, so he can play 80 minutes in the backrow if things are going your way, or move out to the centres (a better centre than Tom Symonds) or hooker if injury occurs. He is a competitor who gives 100% in attack and defence; full throttle. I think our backrow next year should be:

11. Brown
12. Symonds
13. Buhrer

All three are capable of playing 80 minutes and are very mobile. I don't mind so much if we let Mateo go, but if he stays then he can come on as an impact player with Symonds to have a rest.
 
There must be something about him that coaches can see but we can't.
When Cleary left the Warriors he took Brown with him and now Barrett is doing the same.
 
Alright, so I've been criticised for labelling this guy a lemon after watching him for 30 minutes 😉

Lets see how he does against a really **** team.

NYEagle
 
I'm not going to bag the guy. He definitely has a go.

I'll grant that he's got versatility.

But so far I haven't him do anything that Sao, Lui or Horo can't do.
 
Hmm 3 runs for 25 metres at half time.
I know he came off, but not exactly a guy that looks for work is he?
NYEagle
 
Hmm 3 runs for 25 metres at half time.
I know he came off, but not exactly a guy that looks for work is he?
NYEagle
In his defense this has been the lowest game of football I've seen in years. Lackluster doesn't quite describe it..
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

2025 Ladder

Team P W D L PD Pts
1 Raiders 20 16 0 4 152 36
2 Storm 19 14 0 5 228 34
3 Bulldogs 19 14 0 5 122 34
4 Warriors 19 12 0 7 26 30
5 Panthers 19 11 1 7 83 29
6 Broncos 19 11 0 8 124 28
7 Sharks 20 12 0 8 43 28
8 Dolphins 19 10 0 9 171 26
9 Roosters 19 9 0 10 20 24
10 Sea Eagles 19 9 0 10 6 24
11 Dragons 19 7 0 12 -58 20
12 Tigers 20 8 0 12 -121 20
13 Cowboys 20 7 1 12 -177 19
14 Knights 19 6 0 13 -116 18
15 Eels 19 6 0 13 -153 18
16 Titans 19 5 0 14 -153 16
17 Rabbitohs 20 6 0 14 -197 16
Back
Top Bottom