[Resurrected] Season 2018 your predictions

[Bearfax]

I said finish top 4 with no injuries or in the arse end of the 8 . Should of said arse end of the bottom 8.

I know how you feel Brad. I saw them as maybe 6-3 without injuries about 11th if with injuies with a general feeling of 7-8. I seriously underestimated the loss of Green and the exiling of Hastings. The loss of Sironen had much more impact than I expected. Being without Walker for lengthy periods has impacted badly. But also Manly's back up players chosen in the 30 should have included more of the young guns like Anderson, Funa, Fainu, even Cust. A full strength Manly could have achieved the 8 maybe as close as 4. But next year Manly needs a couple of solid forwards and to bring up the young players into the 30 so we have something to play around with.rather than a bunch of second graders who offer safe and slow only.

 

[BrendonStarr]

I just casted my vote.

Bottom 4 ( of top 8)

 

[Mark from Brisbane]

Injuries and the instability of a different team EVERY week has killed off any chance of making the top 8.

And from the performance on Thursday night it’s clear the players know it and no longer give a ****!!

Which is sad, as where there’s breath there’s hope!

 

[BrendonStarr]

Having Paseka back will be massive, Jorge is looking good, we obviously need Tom & Jake in the team every week, time to give M.Wright the flick and Have T.Wright in the 17,

Hoping that Hodkinson can find some form, he has been terrible in my opinion.

DCE needs to pull his finger out and get his kicking game right.

The players need to watch that Brocos game a few times during the week and remember how to play as a team. We need to rediscover that form to knock over the Warriors, Dragons, Panthers and get our season back on track.

 

[BOZO]

We will finish where we deserve

 

[Jethro]

Bump this thread
How are all our predictions looking now?

I said somewhere between 5th and 10th so so far, I'm not too far off the lower end of my prediction and I still think that 10th is still achievable come season end.

 

[pjayz]

I said somewhere between 5th and 10th so so far, I'm not too far off the lower end of my prediction and I still think that 10th is still achievable come season end.

Haha - remind me not to bet with you

You predict they’ll finish between 5th and 10th, talk about a bit each way - so you are saying they will either make the top 8 or miss out...

 

[Jethro]

Haha - remind me not to bet with you

You predict they’ll finish between 5th and 10th, talk about a bit each way - so you are saying they will either make the top 8 or miss out...

I'm a Libran so I'm a bit of a

with a lot of things in life.

 

[CorkQld]

I said 6th, now I’m aiming for 15th, do we a certificate of participation or something like at school even when u come second last in the cross country

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Well a new year has officially begun (in most advanced counties, anyway) so before all the 2019 prediction threads spring up I thought it was appropriate to remind us of how bad we are at predictions.
I had us top 4 in 2018!

This post is dedicated to promoting respect for the quality of humility, and in celebration of human frailty.

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Good work Neville!

Before you laugh too loud, only 4 posters picked us 13th-16th!

 

[manlyfan76]

Good work Neville!

Haha classic!
You would easily be the funniest, smartest and best informed fan on this site.

 

[globaleagle]

Undefeated.

I wuz robbed!

 

[Harvies elbow]

4-8 or better for me.
We'll make the 8. We play better when we are written off.

Yes well .
Obviously the after effects of the lobotomy...

 

[manlyfan76]

Thanks mate, appreciate your kind words

I'm not your mate.

 

[Harvies elbow]

So true, but I could not imagine a fan being that pessimistic?
Thank God 2016-2018 are behind us with the imposter

Especially after making the finals the year before.
At no real point was I confident under he who cannot coach, though we did have some good games but could rarely string more than 2 in a row.
Even so, I could not have envisioned how poor we were last year and our position on the table reflected the manner in which we played.
Good riddance...

 

[Bearfax]

Well a new year has officially begun (in most advanced counties, anyway) so before all the 2019 prediction threads spring up I thought it was appropriate to remind us of how bad we are at predictions.
I had us top 4 in 2018!

This post is dedicated to promoting respect for the quality of humility, and in celebration of human frailty.

I also thought top 8 for 2018. Wasn't all Barrett's fault. We had a dreadful run of injuries and lost those close games we were winning in 2017. But my hopes that Barrett had something to offer soon drifted as Manly continually lost, he showed little imagination in strategies, and his selection policy left me gobsmacked. The Perfect Storm of failure. That's why with Des there I cant see has hitting those depths again...but I'm only hopeful that they may squeeze into the 8. But I'm hardly the master of prognostication...cant pick 'em either

 

[EagleFlys]

I picked 9-12, and thought that was giving the lads a chance to outperform. Little did I know Twenty had other plans.