Turbo or Gutho? Who would you prefer?

[PONTIAN SEA EAGLE]

Gutho has come back from an acl & recovered whereas poor tom has injury after injury.Gutho rarely has bad games i‘d have to go for gutho.

 

[Alfreddo]

Let's do the swap now and see us shine!

 

[Alfreddo]

If he was our FB right now we would make the top 6 guaranteed

 

[Ryan]

At least we.can never again talk of Turbo being the greatest Manly fullback. One solitary GOOD season, the rest crap and riddled with injuries on top. What makes it worse is his ridiculous salary demands.

Let any other club pay 20% of their cap for him on the sidelines. It would actually do us a favour.

 

[HK_Eagle]

In hindsight, Gutho obviously.

 

[HK_Eagle]

If he was our FB right now we would make the top 6 guaranteed

“If” is the million dollar word there.

 

[Ned]

Turbo

 

[BOZO]

Gutho is a great competitor
Turbo is the Greatest Fullback in the game
This is why he is a Million Dollar player

 

[HK_Eagle]

Gutho is a great competitor
Turbo is the Greatest Fullback in the game
This is why he is a Million Dollar player

He’s a million dollar bench warmer.

 

[BOZO]

He’s a million dollar bench warmer.

Our Greatness is not in never falling
But Rising Every time we fall
Our Greatest Manly Premiership Winning Asset is our Great Tom Turbo

 

[HK_Eagle]

Our Greatness is not in never falling
But Rising Every time we fall
Our Greatest Manly Premiership Winning Asset is our Great Tom Turbo

You behave like a bot moron, Bozo. You conveniently attack players you don’t like and defend those you do… and yet, the difference in performance is often negligible. So, given a decade of ongoing injuries and failures to even play finals, how would we judge the Pinto!

 

[Terry Zarsoff]

Turbo

Gubo - both players genes placed in a test tube, a bit of hocus pocus and you wind up with the RL equivalent of Milton the Monster.

 

[Ashton Davis]

Gutho never should have left. Somebody at our club with brains extended him til 2017 cause they had the right idea. But then he was shipped off in 2015 and we ended up bringing guys in like Walker and Taupau whose careers at Manly were a complete waste. Disappointed

 

[Ned]

Gubo - both players genes placed in a test tube, a bit of hocus pocus and you wind up with the RL equivalent of Milton the Monster.

Best of both worlds haha

 

[JakeyB789]

Gutho never should have left. Somebody at our club with brains extended him til 2017 cause they had the right idea. But then he was shipped off in 2015 and we ended up bringing guys in like Walker and Taupau whose careers at Manly were a complete waste. Disappointed

Man I hated Taupau by the end of his time here but we did get a few good seasons out of him mainly when he was up front with AFB. Walker too had some pretty good seasons for us and is still a quality NRL player that I wish we’d kept. Wouldn’t call either of their Manly careers complete wastes compared to some of the other guys we signed in that year

To the point though it’s easy to say now that we’d rather Gutho after Turbo got injured once again, but it’s pretty clear who the better player is when they are both fully fit. Unfortunately for us it just isn’t seeming to work out, bit like keeping Fainu over Api actually. Been a long time since anything went right for this club

 

[HK_Eagle]

Maybe we should tweak our strategy to focus on reliable role players who may not be spectacular, but give us stability?

 

[danny-boy]

If both fit Turbo easy. At the moment you’d take Gutherson because he’s had a good run without injury.

Funny that we handed Gutherson over to the slime and the ****wits still can’t win a premiership. They give us Jamie Lyon and we win two premierships.

 

[eaglebuzz]

If both fit Turbo easy. At the moment you’d take Gutherson because he’s had a good run without injury.

Funny that we handed Gutherson over to the slime and the ****wits still can’t win a premiership. They give us Jamie Lyon and we win two premierships.

Wouldn't you just kill for some of that 2008-2011 squad right now. Put Snake, Robbo, Lyon, Matai, Ballin, Kite and Beaver into our current squad (at the age they were then) and we'd be an absolute premiership force

 

[MW66]

At the time the decision was made = Turbo (although not sure why we couldn't have kept both).

In hindsight = Gutho.

 

[TheSoaringEagle2023]

If both fit Turbo easy. At the moment you’d take Gutherson because he’s had a good run without injury.

Funny that we handed Gutherson over to the slime and the ****wits still can’t win a premiership. They give us Jamie Lyon and we win two premierships.

They gave us Wolfman ...we win a premiership.