Matai stays

[Clint]

Beaver
Cliff
Tooves
Jamie
Brett

 

[Budgie]

Gosh. Too many for just five. But Cliffy, Tooves, and Beaver will forever be my top three. Oh, and then there's Wombat, and oh ...

 

[mickqld]

1. Wombat/Snake
2. Killer
3. Beaver
4. Bozo
5. Cliffy/Igor

 

[mickqld]

If you're looking at Manly's best players & had the most influence on a team/premiership then it's gotta be
1. Bozo
2. Cliffy
3. Snake
4. Wombat
5. Killer

 

[BOZO]

My personal top 5
Fulton ( Immortal. )
Wombat (Finesse of a back and power of a forward. 2 for the price of one )
Mal Reily ( Skill and Steel)
2V ( Phar lap . All heart . Pound for pound the toughest )
Max Brown ( Did not represent Australia but he represented Manly in our first 2 grand final wins ( '72 and '73) Secure , Speedy and Sensational finisher .

 

[Brett#1]

Whats the title of this thread again?

 

[BOZO]

Whats the title of this thread again?

Silvertails Forum 🙂

 

[Budgie]

Whats the title of this thread again?

We are Sea Eagles We can do anything!

 

[niccipops]

Too many to decide. I'm going to cheat and go past and current players based on who I've had the pleasure of watching on many occasions at Brookie.

Past guys In no particular order:
Cliffy
Wombat
Beaver
Igor
Toovey
(the reason I have left out *Fulton is because this is a personal list and I didn't get to see him play much. I think he'd moved to Easts before I became a Brookie regular. I understand his Manly and immortal status.)
*special mention to Gifty Stewart

Present guys/no order- well maybe.....
Snake
Matai
Jamie
Matty.B
*DCE/Foz
*If there's any departure announcements there'll be an immediate axing from the list.

 

[The Wheel]

Can't believe no one has included Ian Martin - 4 time premiership winner

 

[Go manly]

Ken authurson
Rex mossip
Ron willey
Malcolm Johnson
TBA

 

[BOZO]

Can't believe no one has included Ian Martin - 4 time premiership winner

They are all great mate . They all made us proud 🙂

 

[WESTIE]

Matai is my favourite player in the team and has been for some time...his runs from dummy half are very underated IMO..and he is the player opposition fans hate the most , making my " man love " for him even greater....great to hear he might be re-signing.

 

[Brett#1]

We are Sea Eagles We can do anything!

Maybe we just need one giant thread about everything lol

 

[SeaEagleRock8]

Max Brown ( Did not represent Australia but he represented Manly in our first 2 grand final wins ( '72 and '73) Secure , Speedy and Sensational finisher .

Founder of Men of League

 

[Shoe1]

My personal top 5
Fulton ( Immortal. )
Wombat (Finesse of a back and power of a forward. 2 for the price of one )
Mal Reily ( Skill and Steel)
2V ( Phar lap . All heart . Pound for pound the toughest )
Max Brown ( Did not represent Australia but he represented Manly in our first 2 grand final wins ( '72 and '73) Secure , Speedy and Sensational finisher .

Max brown sounds like an early 70s version of robbo.

I only have seen him play in the gf DVDs but was too young to see him play in person.

 

[BOZO]

Max brown sounds like an early 70s version of robbo.

I only have seen him play in the gf DVDs but was too young to see him play in person.

Founder of Men of League

Good bloke Max . He still keeps fit by running regularly along Avalon beach

 

[bones]

Cliffy
Snake
Matai
Beaver
Gifty

 

[pjayz]

Cliffy
Killer
Snake
Beaver
Tezza

 

[Andrew..]

Lyon's
Randall
Menzies
Krillich
Eadie